Body Corporate for 'Golden Sands Highrise' v Galtos & Anor [2000] QDC 416
7CW1WCNK*¦ $% %% % % %#% %%
%
O3QWDT,¦
?CH;¦KNT*¦
9MCTCNK+¦
OQN7;;9CKA,¦
NSCACK1WCKA¦
7NXQW-¦
ë;dŃs;T÷;TPURŃð;TŃμf;]dRSŃHqõdHŃ
[wf[TwHR¶ŃsUHŃÚâàŃ1h`¦
Sws[;]PHŃ;[SŃP]RāPSdRTŃfP]ŃU;HŃąı{Ń
ôPU[TSŃqSRŃfq]U;HŃQhfh¦
1h[¦L¦ ¦l¦(((¦
9zzd¦7¦
1h[¦
Tw¦
9;HCY<S<9¦NK.¦ ¦I[dw¦¦
9<HCY<S>9¦1W/¦ 5b[h¦
B<4CLA¦91W<-¦ ¦@hba¦¦
GA<-¦ O9¦Qbz ¦ P7 ¦97F¦
NS9=Q0¦ U§|Ѭ¬|ĪŃĥXŃ{XXX|{ŃĿ±§ŃċijX±XÎŃ
71W7BZNQ9U-¦ 2i\¦¦:{{e¦8¦s¦gj¦k¦2g~g{e]¦gj¦)¦k¦
))$¦ 2gg|e]¦
gjjg¦]j]¦cg¤¦e]j¦¦]{]{¦c¤¦g{u¦¡¦¦
¡]jk¦xj¦k¦k¦{¦c{g{u ¦¡x{ex¦kjg¦]¦k¦j¦k¦xj¦
¦gj¦¦¦)¦k¦xj¦6g¤¦8]j¦]g¦8{¤¦J]]ujj¦
V]g]g¦Jgj ¦Rju]{¦))$¦ jj¦jgj{u¦ex¦
]{j]ej¦jej]¤¦eejg¦cjpj¦!¦E¤¦))$¦¡xj¦¦
¦)¦
e]j¦}¦kej¦ cg¤¦e]j¦eejt¤¦]ujg¦¦
¦)¦xg¦
¦cj¦u{j¦jje{j¦jmje¦ )#"¦ ¦
e{gjjg¦ ]gg{e]¦jjg¦{¦gjj}}u¦yj¦j}¦ju{]{¦
}¦!!# ¦k¦yj¦ )&¦]x{jg¦
xj¦gj¦]gj¦ }koe}j¦j{gjej¦yj¦ gjkje{j¦¡]jnu¦
¡]¦{j¤¦¦]gjj¤¦^mje¦]xj¦¦ ]j_¦g}}jg¦
7NXKT;H*¦ I¦1¦7¢h¦q¦wh¦1h[¦
I¦Q¦W[ h¦r¦wh¦Qhfh¦
TNHC7CWNQT-¦ 1£f¦I[w[¦r¦wh¦1h[¦
Id7vw¦Qbh¦r¦wh¦Qhfh¦
Wwz¦ z¦ [¦ [h[¦ b¥¦wh¦ bf¥¦ d[h¦ [v[z¦ [¦ fh¦ [fh¦ b¥¦[¦ [ffzd[¦
[zhf¦ fh¦ (¦ l¦wh¦ $% % % "!% % %
((%¦¦ 9hdhbh¦))'¦[¦r¡,¦
-- 1 of 9 --
9<$eŃ x<8QeŃ Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń
Ń $ Ń Ń x Ń \ģŃ $ * Ń Z Ń Ń
Ń\ŃZ ?Ń Ńa ŃŃ Ń11Ń
8Ń Ń Ń Ń ŃĤŃn,:Ń ŃŃ ŃŃŃ Ń Ń
ŃŃ ŃŃŃŃŃ Ń- ĖŃ Č Ń Ń
ĆŃŃ 5ŃŃ Ń Ń iŃŃ Ń Ń
Ń Ń ŃŃ Ń11Ń ŃŃ Ń^Ń Ń Ń @Ń ŃŃŃ
Ń j Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń
Ń
8Ń j Ń Ń Ń Ń ŃŃ Ń 11Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń
Ń ķ ŃŃ Ń Ń Ń Ń ŃŃ@Ń & Ń
Ń ŃŃ Ń Ń ĵ ¤ŃŃ Ń Ń Ń Ń
Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń
ÿóeíŃ <v$<Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń
Ń Ń ŃŃ ŃŃŃ Ń Ńa Ń'Ń Ń
ŃŃŃ ŃŃŃŃŃŃŃ' 'ŃŃ %Ń
BŃ ĝ Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń & Ń Ń Ń
¯ Ń ŃŃ Ń Ń 11Ń 'Ń Ń Ń -' Ń Ń Ń
Ńġ ' Ń Ń Ń ŃŃ Ń ľÃã Ń ŃŃ Ń MŃŃ
Ń ŃŃ Ń NŃŃŃ ŃŃŃŃ Ń> Ń
'Ń Ń ŃŃŃ' ŃŃŃŃŃŃŃ'ļŃŃ
EŃ C Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń ' Ń ÄŃ Ń Ń (:Ń
ŃŃ ŃŃ ŃŃ Ń' Ń Ń Ń ·Ń
ý Ńø Ń(FŃŃQ Ń1ŃŃ Ń$ Ń ŃŃŃ ŃŃѸ ŃŃ$ ¹:Ń
Ń Ń Ń Ń ' Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ğ Ń Ń Ń Ń ŃŃ Ń
Ń:Ńc'Ń ŃŃŃ-'ŃŃ
äŃ%F,GF:ÏŃ
$ Ń Ń ŃŃ Ń¤ Ń(Þ Ń()))Ń ŃŃŁŃ 'Ń Ń
ŃŃ2 ŃQ Ń& Ń Ń ŃŃ ŃŃŃŃ Ń 'Ń
Ń Ń ŃŃŃ ŃŃ Ń'Ń Ń Ń& Ń Ń Ń
Ń Ń Ń Ń& Ń(F \' Ń())GŃ Ń Ń$ Ń ŃŃ& @ŃÅŃ
@Ń Ń ¯Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń & ÆŃ Ń Ń
üÜŅÖ˨©ľŪ ĕ©¨ÙŪ ě©ËŪ ĆŖ×ÜªŪ ē¨ÖÙŪ ùģŪ ()p/ÐŃ 8Ń Ń Ń Ń -Ń ¦Ń 2 Ń
Q Ńj Ń ŃŃ Ń¥ Ń Ń æŃ
91Ń < Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń £ Ń Ń Ń Ń *Ń Ń
Ń Ń¦ŃŃ ŃŃ Ń ŃŃZŃŃ
^Ń u Ń Ń (,Ń x Ń ())GŃ Ń Ń Ń
¥ åŃ
(:Ń Ń$ Ħ Ń())1Ń ŃŃ Ń @ŃŃ Ń 5Ń Ń
Ń Ń Ń5 Ń5ŃŃ ŃŃ&ŃŃŃ
-- 2 of 9 --
=Ū
,!$Ū Ķ!|Ū C!Ū 2.,!Ū MŪ $!#Ū 1Ū !Ū #Ū
! Ū$Ū$Ū#ŪŪ 1Ū!Ū$Ū Ū #,6Ū 8$!#Ū
#Ū #,Ū ;Ū C,.$!Ū .Ï?Ū 8$Ū 1Ū #Ū
2.,Ū;Ū,;ŪF **c{Ū
}±Ū úŪ ¾#Ū F **UŪ $Ū #Ū ! Ū #2Ū Ū
2Ū Ū Ū ,,Ū !Ū 2Ū =6Ū 8$Ū 3Ū #Ū
.!|Ū
=±Ū ¾4#!Ū !#!!Ū 1Ū #Ū $Ū ŗ1Ū ;Ū
AŪZ8Ū Ū ĻŪ ķ!Ū Ū $Ū 4ř,Ū .!Ū Ū $Ū
..Ū ,,Ū iŪ }¸Ū $#Ū Ū ,1Ū #Ū Ū !Ū
2Ū=Ū!Ū$Ū#2ŪŪ#Ūi-ŪZŪ$!#Ū!2Ū!ŪO#Ū
,#ŪŪ$Ū$ŪOŪ #,Ū 0#Ū !Ū$Ū Ū
#,?Ū
;Ū ,Ū Ū }cŪ s;Ū F **UŪ Ū ĂŚ#Ū ;Ū þm.Ū
s2Ū A;Ū Č/Ū sŪ ć,#Ū !#Ū $²Ū ,$$Ū
$Ū $/Ū Ū # ##aş,Ū !Ū !!Ū $!#Ū !#á#Ū
2ŪŪ.;ŪiŪ$Ū.!ŪŪ$Ū/2ŪŪ$Ū$!/Ū
/2Ū Ū iŪ!#!!Ū ť.##Ū Ū åŪ $Ū /Ū
$!#ŪO!MŪ ŪŪ../ŪŪ . /ŪO!$Ū$Ū .!Ū#Ū
$Ū #ŪMŪ$Ū/2ŪO#ŪŪ0OμŪ
¡,#Ū !Ū$Ū 2mÕ,Ū !#Ū Ū .m®Ū 2Ū Á!Ū Đ!#Ū /Ū Á2Ū
//Ū}cŪs;Ū F**UŪ O$! $Ū /Ū ŋ#Ū ÕŪ$Ū #,Ū Ū
$Ū0ņ $ŪŪ 0#ŪŪ$Ū#,Ū!Ū$Ū/2Ū ¯ţæø$! $Ū
!Ū!#Ū##2/Ū!#Ū$ŪŁ!/Ū/2ãμŪ ¡Ū.Ř®Ū2ŪďŪ¡ĔŪ
//ŪcŪs;Ū F **UŪ,!##Ū$Ū #.#Ū 2.,/Ū!ŪŪ2.Ū
Ū # m®!Ū$Ū.ō2ñŪ ÂŪ!#Ū..Ū2Ū$!#Ū$Ū$Ū
aŎ/!Ū MmŪ Ū Ū mm/Ū;Ū cŪ s;Ū F **UŪ /Ū
iŪF } Ū,;ŪF**UòŪ
¯¸äŪ Ū F F Ū Å2Ū F**UŪ Ą2Ū !#. /Ū $Ū !Ū /Ū
/Ū#!#ŪMŪŪ!##ó2ŪŪ$Ū,0$/ŪŪ
.ŪMŪ$Ū !,!Ū ##ŪŪ.##Ū,!ŪŪ 2Ū=Ū
$! $Ū #Ū Ï#Ū ! Ū Ū ÷Ū Ū F **UŪ ;Ū $Ū
#./#?Ū
U?Ū 8$Ū B! Ū i/Ū $Ū o? ? 6 Ū $Ū #Ū MŪ $Ū Ū
.!Ū Ū $Ū ,Ū 4!#Ū.!ŪŪ $Ū 22 2Ū MŪ
$ŪĘOĚŪZ ŪŪF = Ū,;ŪF **U?pŪ
ÂŪ 2;Ū Ū $Ū 2Ū $Ū i!Ū $Ū $Ū #./#zŪ ,Ū ,Ū ccŪ !#Ū Ū
.$#Ūij !,;Ū! .!Ū$ŪMŪMŪ$Ū,ŪŇ,!|Ū8$Ū.$#Ū
!ŪĮ Ū !#Ū OŪ,,#ŪŪO$! $Ū..#ŪŪ./ Ū$Ū ,!Ū MŪ!#Ū Ū
,OŪ ĸ#Ū MŪ $Ū !,/!Ū Ū Ū !Ū ,,Ū đ²Ū O$! $Ū Ū Ū $/Ū ;Ū Ū
-- 3 of 9 --
-
^b^xtXxX¨Xa ¤ux^u ubb^ ba XbXx \XxX¨ bX
^bXbXa [bX ¤uy^u ^X\bb {¨ba\¨ ub¤b RXa¨x uX \bt
bX~ X\bXXb¨ ba^baxub ubbu b E¤b¡b ub
\a¨^Xb uXb xba¤xuX b¡xXbtXx uX¤~ ab\¨ub
bab b¡x¤bc00^bXba ub \b
Sub bab ^^bs Xx^Xx ¤ux^uubXa{ax^X abb xba )
@b^b\b' 332 ¤X \Xba ' &3 cub =a¨ ?Xb Xa?y«
KYXtbbRXaXa Kab QbtXx' 3 31 ¤vz^u Xxb ub \{b^
\xaxtF xx X4
Sub \a¨^Xb XxXx ^
b¨
ta ^axxx ^axtvb b¦bvX ^
b¨x ^XxXb xX^X¨ a
^axx
Sub b¦b uX x^abaxvb^vbbXb^bXba
abX ]xaxtnXXd]ax¡xxub \a¨
^Xb
X XxXxx ta ^axx
x XxxtXX b Xa]XXab¤vbvb b^xb©
nXX^x^X b vb] aXªdX Xa
^ b¨7Xa
xx a ¤xa¤Xa X^xXba kwtw XbaxX
]aXª¤XbXXxtX p
^b©8
Xa
xxx kt b]Xb vXXb ^
b¨] vX
¡xabb^xn ^ b¨9
@bxb Xªuxtx \b^x ' Xa *
Xvb \a¨^Xbx bx]bn XxXxxtl¦b
lxtxXba\¨ vb ^^xbdX xd ub¨ ¤bb
xXban ub ^^xb ¤]bbl9 Xa
SX¡xa a]xx ab^XbauX abxbX \xtXx ub \a¨
^Xb X¨ uX¡b ab \b^x+ XxXxXXdX
xta ^axxxX ^X¨ a ^axx ub\a¨
^Xbx b¡bbaq b^¡bxtXX c aXXtb
qXb ¤ubub vb ¤bc vb ¤ub X^x
^Xb^ z\b aXXtb abbzXxd ubXcub
,q ¤X^ ta vbb b¦xbaX\xaxtn XXc
\ax¡xxubb
-- 4 of 9 --
0Ń
X ŃŃ ŃŃŃŃŃ ŃŃ6Ń Ń/)ŃŃŃ Ń ŃŃ
Ń ŃŃ Ń Ń ŃŃŃ Ń Ń 4Ń
Ń ŃŃ ŃŃ Ń ŃŃŃ*Ń4ŃŃŃ
ŃŃ ŃŃŃ@ŃŃ ŃŃ Ń!ŃŃŃŃ
ŃŃ*ŃŃŃì²k©¢kbğŃþbkD°Ń b¢Ńñ«²®ŃûkD©}°ŃrzDŃY )p/Ń9Ń Ń$ L!Ń
Ń ?Ń ŃŃ ŃŃ ŃŃ Ń Ń ŃŃi Ń
ŃěŃŃ ŃŃŃ-Ń
u ŃŃŃŃ ŃŃŃŃ ŃŃŃ Ń4Ń
Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń ħ \ Ń Y ))á.Ń Ń
= Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń "Ń $ @Ń Ń Ń 6,,0!Ń ŃMŃ
ŃŃ Ń=iŃ Ń Ń ŃŃ" ŃŃŃ2ŃŃ2Ń
Z ŃŃŃAŃ^ Ń,,0!ŃçŃ
cß!Ń ŃË
!Ń Ń ŃŃ"Ń ŃŃŃ ŃŃŃ"ŃŃ"Ń
ŃŃ l "Ń£ Ń ŃV ŃŃ Ń "J"Ń Ń V Ń
ŃŃŃ"ŃŃŃŃ"Ń4ŃŃ"ŃŃŃ
ŃŃŃ ĭŃéŃŃ
!Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń ".Ń MŃ "Ń Ń Ń
ŃŃŃ Ń0 Y ŃŃ"Ń!Ń!!ŃăĀŃŃŃ"Ń
ŃŃ Ń Ń ŃŃŃŃ Ń ŃŃŃŃŃŃ
Ń Ń Ń 0 " !!ÇŃ Ń Ń ćĻŃ "īMŃ Ń Ń ³Ń
*MŃ ŃŃ ŃJŃŃŃ ŃŃ ŃŃ ºŃ
_Ń= ŃŃC Ń4ŃEŃ"ŃŃ Ń$ ŃŃŃ4 MŃŃŃ
Ń ŃŃ Ń cŃ l "Ń Ń ÑŃ%ŃAŃ J"Ń Ń V Ń Ń
Ń Ń "Ń Ń Ń Ń m!Ń "Ń 4Ń Ń Ń Ò Ó % ŃŃ Ń
Ń LŃ Ń = Ń "Ń Ń c"LŃ V %Ń 2Ń tŃ
ŃŃŃŃ Ń Ń Ń ŃŃŃiAŃŃŃ*ŃŃŃ
ŃŃŃŃ "JŃ ŃŃŃ J@ŃŃŃŃ JŃŃ
Ń ŃŃ 9 ŃĒ L?Ń8Ń Ń ŃŃŃ Ń2Ń _Ń4Ń
Ń!ŃŃŃŃ ŃŃ Ń ŃŃŃJŃ ŃŃ
Ń Ń Ń Ń 9 LŃ Ń 9 L.Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń
Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń
Ń Ń Ń Ń l 6Ń ^Ń ZŃ Ń gŃ Ń u Ń
8ŃÁgŀÂŃgŃĂ Y)0pĄŃFŃ$ "Ńe6Ń0 0 Y 6 Ń
-- 5 of 9 --
Lbbxb ¨K?¤b \xba ub b¡xab_b \bnb ubXa| ax_X ¤X
xem_xb ub b_bX¨ laxt uX _x_X_b b¦xba¤ux_u¤bb
xb¬ Xhb_ ! ubb " " " "Sub b¡xab_b ¤XX b¦b b ub
o¤xtbh b_4
" ¤b _XXg¨Xbubn ¤xt5
X <¨¤ _bba xbXxt ub _X_X ub ¤b
a¤bXba ¤x¨ bx ub¤Xb laxt Xub
_uZb Xa xcbt b
\ FXaaxx ub ¤Xb ¡xt ¤xuz ubX\ ¤x b¡b X¨
bc ub bxn_bb
_ Fubb xXx ub ¤Xb X¨ b¡b\¨XOb ubUz) Xa
lax ¤X¨ub z¤b a¤xub \xaxt#
a Sub ¨bX¨ Xxf_¨¤X¨c_xt ub \bxb¡b
ubxtbc ¤XbX ubxcb ¨
M ?¤b x ¤XuX _ tb¤ubb bX bX\xuxt xbxuaG ¤X
bxabac ubMX_Xxb @x_xX¨abkxxc xb¨Xn¤6
P\X\¨XXb¨ txtabxba a \bb _: xb¨
uXb
Tub XbX \xx¤X uX xb¨n_b ub \X\xx¨cX
b¡b Xub uXX bb x\xx¨MTX¡b`bbaWVxu b§X
b r _Xb
X¤ ¤ubbx Xx_X_b§ xb¨ uX\bb ubaX xXb ab`x\b
_x_X_b ¤ubb ubbx XbX _uX_bx\xx¨$ Rbbnb§X
b
TxX>_ubxbP¢ Ja¡;XXxX MbXGa£ A¡bb Ux
( 313.*CIQ,, ( ,,3 b> ¤b ?H,. 0.1 b@bXb HTubbX axj_¨
x ub¥X¨cu axt uX %,, /X xbxxub xabxl_Xxc Xub uX
X¨\bXi b_ba\¨ ub fxbc ub ¤Xbc b\Xb _XxbaxK Xa
KDX "@XXtbuX uXa uXbba ¤XubXbbaubx¤x
\bxab ub x ubb#B¡b xcxb¨ xtx¡b ub b¦babaxbbXx
_baba nxXbXbuXubb¡xab_b \bnb ubXa} ax_Xub
¤ub Xbxf b#F _X\b Xxax¨ xxx
X¨uxtXtXX bX x\xx¨_uX_b
K¨__x uX,,/cub a<_ xba\xt Xxub \a¨
_Xbx ub_x_ X_b bX ub\x tXxc ub \a¨_ Xb \b
Xbbax xtuc ubXaXa ab ¡xx ¤ Xx_X\b"F Xtbb¤xuN
?¤b \xx uX",1 ( _xxxc ub a <__X ¡xabXX bXx¡b
-- 6 of 9 --
GŃ
ĊyŃ ęŃ Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń A,,0!%Ń 8Ń Ń ĮÜÙ.Ń Ń
K ŃaŃ aŃŃŃŃŃŃ9I*ŃŃIŃ o %Ń ŃŃŃ
Ń ĚŃ Ń Ĺ ŃŃŃ ŃŃ Ń ŃŃ Ń Ń o»Ń8Ń
Ġ ŃK Ń2ŃQŃ Ń Ń,,0!ŃŃ,GŃŃ Ń Ń~Ń .Ń
y Ń Ń Ń Ń .ŃŃ ŃŃ aÈŃŃI*ŃŃIŃŃ Ń AŃ
ù ŃO/O!Ń Ń ŃrzDĺŃòbD}®}D DĨ«bŃrzDŃ(70.ŃŃ Ń Ń Ń Ń4Ń
ŃŃÔ(/7Ń Ń ŃŃ Ń I*ŃŃ ŃŃ ŃŃŃ
y ŃŃ ŃŃ Ń*ŃŃŃ(OŃ Ń(77GŃèŃ
N < Ń ŃŃŃ ŃŃ$ ŃŃŃÌ
!Ń Ń ŃŃŃ4 ŃŃ*ŃŃ ŃŃ Ń ŃŃ
Ń5ŃC ŃŃ
!Ń C Ń ŃŃŃ Ń Ń$ ŃŃ Ń~ŃŃ
ŃŃ Ń$ êŃŃ
Ń !Ń C ŃŃ Ń ŃŃ Ń ĶŃ ŃŃ Ń
Ń Ń$ ŃŃ
Ń!Ń C ŃŃ Ń ŃŃ ŃŃŃC ŃŃŃ
Ń$ ŃŃ
Ń!Ń čĎ Ń Ń Ń hŃ Ń hŃ Ń Ń Ń Ń
Ń Ń ŃŃ ŃhŃŃĈ ŃŃ !ŃŃ
,!Ń < ŃŃ ŃŃªŃŃŃŃ ŃŃ
ŃŃ Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń& Ń Ń
Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń
A
Ń
2ŃtKŃ Ńĸ ŃŃF! !Ń8Ń ŃK Ń ³ŃŃ NŃŃªŃŃ
Ń Ń Ń ŃŃ ŃŃŃŃ ŃŃ Ń ŃŃ
Ń&Ń(O \ Ń Û 77GŃŃ Ń Ń Ń 5Ń Ń Ń ŃŃ
Ń oŃg .Ń%ŃŃ/7O!Ń Ń ŃŃ Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń
ē Ń Ń Ń Ń %Ń < Ń Ń Ń .Ń Ń
´ .Ń Ń AŃŃ/7O!Ń ŃŃ Ń Ń ~ AŃ $ Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń
Ń Ń Ń Ń C Ń Ń EŃ Ń Ń Ń Ń
ŃŃ Ń Ń ŃŃ ŃŃŃ Ń Ń
*%Ń< .ŃŃ- Ń Ń Ń ŃKŃ ŃŃ Ń ŃŃ
´Ń ŃŃ ŃŃŃŃŃhŃ ŃIŃŃ Ń4Ń
ŃŃ Ń Ń Ń Ń K Ń Ń Ń IŃ Ń Ń Ń Ń
Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń -Ń Ĝ%Ń 8Ń Ń Ń Ĕ Ń
K ŃŃŃ Ń Ń Ń Ń-Ń ŃŃŃ Ń
-- 7 of 9 --
VŪ
¡W W ŃŃ ŃŃŃŃŃ Ń Ń ŃŃ6ŃĬŃ/7nF:6Ń
BŃŃŃ Ń & Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń
¡WŃ Ń * ŃŃ Ń Ń+Ń Ń Ń ?ŃŃ ŃŃ
¨ Ń9WŃ ¼Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń * Ń ÕŃ
î Ń Ńĉ` ŃŃ Ń ?Ń ŃŃ Ń+Ń Ń Ń+Ń Ń
WŃ`5 Ń- Ńn Ń ŃŃ ŃŃ Ńj :ŃŃŃ Ń Ń+Ń Ń
+ŃŃ ŃŃ Ń İ Ń+ŃŃŃ/7Ń & ŃŃ Ń Ń Ń Ń
Ń Ń ŃŃ Ń ŃŃ ŃŃŃ 5%ŃBŃ Ń Ń ŃŃ
Ń Ń Ń ŃŃ ŃŃ Ń ŃŃ Ń Ń öŃ Ń
Ń >?Ń Ń Ń + Ń Ń Ń Ń ŃŃŃŃ Ń Ń
Ń ŃŃ EŃ V NŃ Ń Ń Ń & Ńł Ń ` Ń Ń
ŃŃ%(/)%Ń
ú¨ Ń # ŃŃ Ń Ń Ń Ń > Ń * Ń Ń # Ń >Ń+Ń% Ý /)ÉŃ Ń
įŃ Ń# Ń Ń ŃŃ# Ń >ŃÖŃ Ń# ŃWÚŪÃWªWÈWňŕŪ
WŪ Ń Ń Ń BŃ Ń >EŃ Ń #Ń Ń V 3Ń ďŃ 3Ń Ģ Ń Ń
3Ĵ ŃŃ Ń Ń×ŃBŃ#>ĩŃŃŃŃ 3>Ń+Ń# Ń Ń Ľ Ń
IJŃ ŃWÚŪ ÃWªWÈWʼn×Ū WŪ ŃŃ#Ń# Ń >3 Ń+ŃŃ Ń Ń ŃŃ
3W Ń Ń# Ń Ń$3Ń ŃŃ# Ń 5Ń#3#Ń# Ń=3 Ń ŃŃ Ń
ŃŃŃ ŃŃѽ ¾Ń Ń¿ ÀŃ - Ń Ń3 l Ń Ń# Ń Ń$3%Ń
ï Ń # Ń # Ń +Ń # Ń ÊŃ 2 Ń Q Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń
ĐėŃ ŃŃ Ń mŃ ŃŃŃŃ ŃŃ # Ń
ŃŃ Ń +Ń Ń+Ń Ń ØŃ _ ŃŃŃ NŃBŃ EŃŃŃ Ń
ĕŃ Ń 2 Ń _ mŃ Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń & Ń Ń
t :NŃ Ń & Ń Ń Ń Ń * Ń %Ń 2 Ń _ Ń = Ń Ń
Ń+Ń Ń 6Ńv Ń ?Ń ŃŃ `Ń EŃ Ńđ Ń Ń Ń
Ń& Ń Ń= Ń Ń Ń Ń# %ŃBŃ 5Ń ŃŃ%Ń
ü# Ń= Ń Ń Ń Ń `Ń& Ń Ń Ń ŃŃ Ń Ń
Ń Ń 6Ńv NŃ ŃŃ Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Ń Í ŃŃ
Ń - 6Ń ^ 5Ń& Ń Ń ?Ń BŃ Ń Ń Ń = Ń
Ń Ń 9 Ń Ń Ń ŃŃ Ń Ń Ń - Ę Ń Ń Ń
-- 8 of 9 --
:b]e8_}rcv_=>ir8Y> 8_=;c^e[>r>rR> z8r>kejccDU_O -r To c_[} rc9> >{e>;r>=
rR8rrR>9c=};ckeci8r> c_rR>c_>R8_= 8_=/i8_=/io*8[rco c_rR>crR>i ^8~
R8x> x>i} =TG>i>_r xT>zo 8o rc rR> zciY rR8r cvORr rc 9> =c_> rR>or8_=8i= c A
K_ToR>o8_=rR>[TY>-ro>>^orc^>rRToToT_R>i>_rT_8oTrv8rTc_zR>i>zciYR8orc
9>=c_>8rrR>>|e>_o>cA% zR>i>8o'c9r8T_orR>ei8;rT;8[9>_>Jr ciToov9W>;r>=
rcrR>cvr;c]>cArR>zciY-rST_YrR>8=Wv=T;8rciz8pe>iA>;r[~iTORrrc=>;[T_>rc
orTev[8r>rR8rzciYcvORrrc9>e[8`_>=8_==c_>rcrR>o8rToE;rTc_cA/i8_=/io
*8[rco7Rc>x>ie8}orR>eTe>icvORrrc9>89[>rc;8[[rR>rv_>-_^}ceT_Tc_ rR>
9c=};ckeci8r> cvORrrcR8x> 8 i>8oc_89[}zT=>=To;i>rTc_ T_ =>r>j^T_T_O Rcz Tr
;8jiT>ocvrTroc9[TO8rTc_-r]8}z>[[9>c9W>;rTc_89[>rR8rrR>[crcz_>io8o89c=~
oRcv[=R8x>rce8}9>}c_=rR>]T_T]v]_>;>oo8j}rcejcxT=> 89vT[=T_O rR8r=c>o
_cr[>8Y-A/i8_=/io*8[rcoz8_r^cj>e>jR8eorR>}zT[[R8x>rce8}MiTr-=c
_crzToRrc8_rT;Te8r>=TI;v[rT>o38rR>j-zcv[=8_rT;Te8r>8orR>8=Wv=T;8rcj=T=
rR8r rR> e8jrT>o zT[[8;rj>8oc_89[} T_ rR> Y_cz[>=P> rR8r TA=TH>j>_;>o j>^8T_
8_crR>j 8=Wv=T;8rcj ;8_ 9> >|e>;r>= rc =>;T=> zR8r cvr;c]> zcv[= 9> FTj 8_=
j>8oc_89[>cjrchvcr>o cBrR>_>z&;rXvor8_=>hvTr89[>
5R> =>r>j]T_8rTc_cArRTo 8ee>8[ R8o 9>>_ =>[8>=rc e>mTr rR> 9c= ;cjecj8r> rc
o>;vj>8_ci=T_8jj>oc[vrTc_rR8rrR>8ee>8[9>9jcvPRrrc cx>j;c^>rR>=TCL;v[s
RTo +c_cvi .v=P> 2vTjZ R>[= ;c_Nc_r>= rR> 9c= ;cjfcj8r> 8ee>[[8_r T_ 'c=y
(cncj8r> Mj 4vjA>jo 68r>jo (54 "" x &`Q\8_= 1[8T_r # cA $$$
'jVo98_> $# $$ M[[czT_P RTo +c_cvi .v=P> +8[[ o =>;ToTc_ T_ 5R> 'c=y
(cncj8r> Mj5R> )cj;R>or>j x )& )' 58y[ci &ee>8[ 0c "" c A $$$
$$$ ->|ej>oo_cxT>z 8o rcrR> ;c]9T_>= >H>;rcAo! 8_= o $ cArR>
_>z%;r5R>e8jtT>o 8Pi>>=rRTo8ee>8[ oRcv[=9>R>8j= T_rR>>|e>;r8rTc_ oT_;>
i>8[To>= rR8rrR>i>oc[vrTc_zcv[=9> MitR;c^T_P rc 8vrRcjTo> Tr /} T^ej>ooTc_
z8o rR8r rR>i> zcv[= 9> _c c9W>;rTc_ rc 8_ ci=>jT_ =v> ;cvio> awa<gld uwa@
>|r>_=T_OrR>rT^>Mi8ee>8[
5R>8ee>8[oRcv[=9>=To^Too>=Tro>>^o 8_=zTrR;coro 5R?e8jrT>ozT[[R8x>rR>
ceecitv_Tr}rcov9^TrMjcrR>jcj=>jo8Ar>j;c_oT=>j8rTc_cArR>o>i>8oc_o
-- 9 of 9 --
Official source: https://www.sclqld.org.au/caselaw/QDC/2000/416