Corrin v Mackay Base Hospital [1998] QIRC 191 (1998) 158 QGIG 21

20 QUEENSLAND GOVERNMENT INDUSTRIAL GAZETTE 8 May. 1998 8 May. 1998 QUEENSLAND GOVERNMENT INDUSTRIAL GAZETTE 21 ########################################################## QUEENSLAND INDt;STRIAL RELA'l 101'S COMMISSION hulus1rial Rdmio11., .·\cl /990 ,. 295 - applicati<>n for rcin,1a1cmcm Chris Corrin AND Ma,l,1y l:la,c Hospi1al !No.112/76 4l<J9()J COMMISSIONISR SW,\:,-.i �x Apr il I 9'!ti Applka1io11 for rci1btaw111c111 - H..:.1rJ Pur,,u,un ,,, the f11d11.\lrio/ /1('/utiom An /990 - Unrcprc,cn1cJ l'am fkfor-, the Commi,sion - Counsdlin� und (juidancc Offerc'<.I "' Applica,;t - Applicant', lkha1 iour lnappropri;,e - C'on,1an1 C,lmplain1, M:1tk hy Applio.::ull - Conilicl in the Workplace Su,pirion ,111d Pcr,ccu1ion Allc•�ation, .• Oimin i.,hcd Wor � Pcrl,irmancc Pnx-c,sc,; in Place - Appli<.:anl Fail, '" Rt·,rond 1,, Pr•x:cs,c, - Employc r Elc..:t, ll> Tcrminalc Service, - Applic:nion DisnlbM..'tl - Tcnnin:,1ion Ju:--tifit:d in 1hc Circumstan"'·c�. DECISION M, C Corrin was tli.,mi"ed from ha fl<"ilion as Enmlkxl Nur,,· at the Y1a,kay Base Ho,piwl flhc Hrn,piwlJ <111 9 Dc-ccmb.:r I \19() f,,r rca,on, rcl;,11ing. tt, poor pcrfurmanc.: and hchaviour. Thi� matter i;,; d�1crminc<l pursuant 10 th� <li...;mis�al jWO\'l!->H.m� llf 1hc f11d11s1riul Relation., Ac/ /99U i lhc At:1). Thi, ,·asc ha, 1ak<.:n c,,n,idcra1,1c time 10 come 10 tn:tl. Thi� ha, ranly tx:�11 due lo lhc fact that a numh\!r of(.;unfcrcnce" havt:: cnsth..'<.I ix-for� aO(Hh1;r Comnii"ioncr for the purpose or n:,oh-ing the i,suc� lx:t"wccn 1.hc panic, in a manner whkh would olwiatc th� nc('d fnr a Lrial. Th� n.::-.p1.,n<..kn1 ln this matter. th...: Hospi1al. wa� n.:prt�ntctl hy th(' Dcpar1111cn1 of Quccn,land Hcahh flhc Ikpartllll'l1l ). M, Corrin n.:prcsc111cd hcr...:lf. l'r iur tu lh,, he.iring p11>1:>,;r. the Dq1ar11n,·n1 haJ '""-'!!Ill 111 have the matter stnll'k 0111 on thl' ground, tint the relief ,ou!,!111 h\ M, Con-in. ic n..�i11;,;Lah.: 1m.:11t. w;,1..; onauainahlc a� !Vh Coffin wc1..., th> lon!!cr 1x::�btcrcd a'.-- an t'nrolbl :'-!ursc !\rnwi1li-1anuing thi,. Ms Cor.-in ht'id ,;, h,·r ',icw lhal ,he tk::--irc;J r�insta1c1nent and ii wa:-i cxplaini.:d h) h�r. Lhal "' en; lhi!-> lo he ..imp1ac1ieahlc··, ,>1her form, or relief 11,ay he ,m,ilahk ,,, h-:r \\CIY ,he :-.uccl',,l'ul in her ,:laim. rvh Corrin a...:k111m h.�d�.;tl thi, po:-.�ihk =--t·cnaril, an<l I ,k1crmincd '" hear iht· mallcr hc�;,usc. on 1hc fac1s a, lhL·y ,wotl, M, Corrin wa..., t.;mitlc<l 10 li1it!ale her daiin. �1s Corr in pu1 her t..:il:-,t,.: lo 1hc ('onHrn:-.sion in a k·ngLhy ;,nd ,,orn._..,,h;.11 c.Ji�jo1ntc-d mann1..·r. 1-\ lttl',!!l' amourn ()f dc�:t1H1l•n1ary material \\•a, pu1 hcl(,re th� Cnnuni:-.,-,iun. f\lls (\,1Tm pn..:'i(·nh.:d a'! ;.t \H'II mcanin� hut oJlkiou:-. pt.'l''-<'11 who pr<1fo.,��d de...·p conn..'nl aht1ul hc..·r work cnvironmc111 and the Glfl." <ll' paLknb. I did 1wl quc:-ition th...: gt.'nuinern..-�� ,li li.:r ha:,,k· h1..:lit.:r�. There i, liulc Jouh1 that M, Corrin ra,cd 1hs: I) !>C ,,!' tlitlicult1 m,"t unrcpn.:�nlcd partic:-. foci: in lil!ga1ion. rv11s Corrin wa� afforded all approprialL' as"btanc.:c frt)m thi.: C()mnfr-.,ion in unch.'r:,.tandint: tlh.' rdc,am l.c-g.i:-.b1it1n and th.._• pnl(,,,'C:-.:--�:-. of' l h:.' (\unmi,"'u,n in h\.·arim.:. l.�nforttinatdv. M, Ct1rri11 did 11<,1 readily "t:cq,1 adYic-C frnrn 1!1� fkn.:11 "1th r,·�arJ ;., L cgi,l�Jli\'C p1·0,·i,il>lh and uft..:n appi.:'ar...�d l�\ he unduly :-.u:,,piL'inu� of an: �ugg�,tion:-. nmdc 10 a:-.�i'it ht.:r. HctllUSC (lf' the hrc•adih and IIUlllrC of '.\1, Cnrrin' s ca,;c. I ll!oudll i1 apprnprlau.· h> ini1ially d�t�1il thl' i:rnpln�1..•r·� r;Hio11:1le flH' tli!--mi:-.,ing l;t.::r. I will then c·o11lparc M� C,1rri11·s 1\'.Sll\m,,.;, 10 1h,1sc concern, tO!!Cther with anv other '-pt:-dfic fa<.·tor, �hi.: 1:-x!licn::-. appl'opriall' for nh: h> ;;:onsi<i•r. � The Ho:-.pital daiml.'ll 1ha1 !v1' Corrin \,a, 11ot comrx·1c:nt in her rnlt: •is an Enrolled �ur,c: that ,h,· 11·.i, a ,akly risk to paticm,: that she "a, unable H• work in a team en, iromncnt and 1hat her "orkplat:1..' bcha\ iuur wa:-: " d i,rup1i,c :,n(I an1ag,mi"i( 10 other ,,an-·, lkc-au-.c or these rn1l\:crn,, the H ospital aucmp1ctl to r,xtify the situa1inn h) pro"idin;; �oun:-.clling. (111 1hc ,j,)h trainin�. p..:ri'onn�,ru.:c imprlwemc.111 2(l.'i24__ I .DOC -- 1 of 2 -- QUEENSLAND GOVERNMENT INDUSTRIAL GAZETTE 8 May. 1998 pnx:,:,...:, :1 11d mctlia11on 10 !\I, Cornn v:ith link· 111 no ,m:L'-"''· II "a' daimc-<l 1ha1 .\1, Corrin ··,·nuld 111,1 untlrrstaml pr r,>lluw in,1n1.;1ion,. rcfus.:d h., �ill'') oul 111,trulll\lfl,. ...·(1n1inually tllh.·,ti,lf'k.'\.l l� authc"·11� of �nit-.r '-11..tlf and ,hnwctl di-.,n.'-.f)l'l'l t� 1r "�11il1r i,.l at f and t:o ll�Hgut·�··. l o dah,,r:11c upon 1ho"' daun,. 1h,· fnllo\\lfl)! c,11k;:11,,: "'" put ti.!lnn: lhr CtimmJ,,iun from n.·,p,mJ1.;rn ,,itnc,�,. 1\1, I� Clm: un, 11 ..:,d J Rcl'i,Lcrcd ·ur,,· al the lln,pi 1:d1 '"" rn1ph1;,.:d a, 1h..• Clino,.il ur-.:- Con,uham tsu1x:r,i,or1 ol the Ccn1101I S1erili,i11)' \upply DcpHnn1cm (CSSI)) from i<)()1 111 l;,1,• 11)96. h>r ,11111,: ul 1ha1 timc. i..- u111il Jun,· 199.l .\1' C1>1Ti11 ""' cmpluy,:d in C:SSI) i\1, Ch1,1111i d:1i111, Ihm durin� lh" pcri, ><l M, Corrin ha,1 foibl 10 lun1..·thrn �td�Ll llatd� tl' an l+,nrolk<l �ur'C Th,..., fo1lutt.· "''-'Ill 1,1 rn.tlli:r.-. .... ud1 a:-- an inahtli1� to 1..ompk:t\' t.t:,,k, wnhin ;ippn)pliate um� lh111tc�. Then: ,H.:r\.' ul""1 uut\.�t <k!li<.:i...-,11.:il•.., 111 the pron.•:,,..,1n� JntJ a.....,,_,·mhl� nl i1htiumt.•nt.r1iun I\H' u-...· in ,,11 f!1<:al prn,e,lurr, M, Chk'oni hd 1..:1ctl th;,1 i\1, (Prrm h:,d a ,h11r1 conn.·n1rJti,u1 "f)all �md ci1hcr "il1111fly 1μnor1..xl m,truclion, or ,1mpl: d1U not ,mdcrstaud the ,mpnnan.:1: uf 1ht 111'lm,uon. A, a <'011 .... -qui:111:c ol thi, p<.,r 1">1;r1t wm,mc�. �I!-- C, )ff in ,, a� ol ten ln t;.'( )I\ lli...:-1 ,,·i1 h ( ,lh,,;r �,aft' ll1\!lllh1.•1·!--. l1ht;111..:..:-, \\.Crc dtl.'\J ,,h1.:rc �·h C1.uTIO would he �nn,, n 10 h:t\'l' nol 1>.:rh•m,.-.J a lmwtinn fll<'f"'rl� . liu1 "ht:fl' ,Ill· ,11\,:1}, claimed chat it ""' anoth1..'r', lault. Cn1P,ta111 1.:omplmnl:-. had tx.·...:n ,rn.i,:?cd t-,� M, (\H't' lll �1 g:11 n,1 uthc1 ,wff meonlx·r, Con"-'tJll<.:llll�. 11 lxY,lllll: � prat'li\:C 1<1 <:1>11fron1 M, (nrn n 1r1 front oi 01h�1· p.:r:-.on:-- in cm.Jcr tot...·n,url' th.ll a c..,)rn..'t:t inh.·rprt·tat1nn t1f 1he <li:..l'u,,ion wa, rrrt)I Lkd. An cxaniplc or p1.¼ll' work practk�, wcnl 10 nut w('aring <1pprop11.11c h>Ul\\<::tr in :t fX�l"llliall� ,0111ami11;11<..·d .1n:,1 nf ('SSD. .\gain,t lht...·....,_• ��n..:ral d.aim,. 'Vh Cnrin ,tah.:-d thtll ,hi.: h.1<l b..:,·n l'on.:i:ll 1" ""'" m the ('SSD p:1r1 1>f th.: 11,,..rit:il again,1 her " tll and chat ,hi: ,houltf ha,.: l'Ctn 1owtetl lllhl nth1..·r l'l<hi1m1 h "i1h111 chi: l Io,pituL 11 wu, ->I t:olll'CI n 11, �1 ... (\,rnn that ...he ,,onld lo� ht.·r rq:i...trntmn a" an 1:nrnlk..-tl :\'w� \\t'� ,k In ,1:1 > ,n c��I) \\ i1hnut clirt'fl pati�lll C<lnl.t(l. Thi, YiC\\ ""' d1-.:1huscd h� nur..,in:! "1t.-1'!'--.c' ,,ho hclie,t•<l rha1 \\hen: \h Cornn \\a, t·mploycd m th...- Hthpllal \\'il", I\Ol the d1..·tcnninant ul' ll'J:!"l1,1tiun I �H.::C\.'pt I..'."\ idl.!fll'l' rr�)lll it...·,p•mdcm \\ lltK''"'-'"' lhat \I, ('curin ,,.1, undl.'r .1 nu-..11)prchl' lhit,n that i1 w;,i, �• pt,il,;� of tht: Ih,.._pllai to u•lah.: I .rirolkd i':ur,1.:,. ·\�.11n,1 1h� d.,1m !hat ,h<' chll ll<ij p.:rl�»·m her ""'" ,1pp<opc iatd� m C'S'il ). i\'h C<>rrrn slated 1ha1 11 1,-,k her ",m,· 1-,,:n,ld ol t,m,• 10 l>c· \;nrn111rtahh: \\ 1th 1..·\.11;11n proCt."tlun·,. I ;t").)11 1.1ul'-...t1uninf .,1._ Chironi. ll app1:,11c..·d th.tt. t.k,pn1..· .,!'\...l"-lalll.,'c.' and ...urpnn. i\·h Con HI CC•lllllltli..�d h> 1x•rfP1m �1dl} 111 .trL'•'' ,ut·h .1, malm� up in,1H111-.:n1 lfi1_,.... \\.'h�n ,.:onfn1111ed "ith I lu..,p1tal 1..·lm;,.;\!rn,. �-1, (·ornn had th� h,thtl nl \\fltlfl!!' h.·n�,h� h..·Ut.·1· , lu h1...·1 c111pln�c..·1 <.:itin� other pt�r,t111, :i, the..· t,n,·, 11\Pr..: .tppi1.1prwtt..·I� 1,, hl�tnw. 1\1' Cun 1n -...t,11c<l 1h.11 ..Jt....:- olico h.'\.'1..'l\'-'d mi\c..'(t nll.·,�.igc� hum 11':r ,11pl·1u1.-... \\tlh rc..:�anl IP ,1pprnp11ak· ,,orJ... pnu.: ,i�L·,. I d1., Jll)t a1..•...cp1 thi:-. <·d<l,:n�<.: I .1111 ,:iu,lied 1h:11 pHx:e,'<', ""'" 111 pla�.- witlltn ihc: CSSD area ot th1.• lto,1,11al for the t·\�1l·ttng '-'l>'� i)I ...:11',uring 1n�1u11K·11t tw:,,, for u-.c 111 th..-:llfc and 01hl'r arL'a, nl' 1h..: Hmp,1:1I \\ ,·r,· a, thl') ,hlluhl Ix· I arn: pl 'vh ('hi,·,,m ·, c111kn,x 1ha1 1\1, Cc,mn ,imply laikd h> u1mrl� ""h thus,: m,tru1.' llOJh fnr a \ 1.tr11.:-l) nr l'L'�1,,,1,,. ,(1J11c (lr \\hiL'h M.'�JHl'd l(l t'Clllrl' upon h:1,1,· ,unlli<:1 hc'l\\L'l:11 ll\'rsdf and (>lhcf ,1.1ff. \\hik· atkmptin:; io doJU'-lh..\.' h> :\1, Corrm·, re,J'<>n�� 1<1 f\1, ('hicl1111· .., 1.' \1tkn�c. r ha\C' luu11d it often d1rfi..:ult lo lull� urn.k•r..,t:1ml lht .i!'"' of �1-... ('nrrin', q:u�·nwru,. 1\,1' Corrin ,1all'<l 1ha1 �hr di,1,.;nvcn:d an u11';t!(° \\('r"- pn.1t.:1it:c.' t,,·curnnr! '"chm th,· (''\SI) .,r,.,. Tiu, ,nwl"·J nul<bk·J Jre,,in� p;,c-�, fi..:m� uuh-..-d \\ ithin tht l 1t,,pi1al \\'�1 rd,. (VI, Cornn dai111, tu h;.1H· d,l\.:urnc111cd hl.'.r �·unlt'llh aod hatl l'011111wn1..·('d pl.1cinf ,1id,�r... on 1h..: p.u..·J.., hl hi_ghlil,!hl thl· 11;.1i111. M, t.'h1cnm rc..·t:al!.... thl' in...:u.h:nl and �1..th.'.., lhal !\b Cornn·, ,1l'tu1n..., "''rL' 111 founch:d .,n,1 had l•c�ll tlw """"-' ,,r eon,idcr;1 hl� rnnlli vl wi1hin the· C<;�I) ar�a .\1- Crn�m hdil•,.:d tl,11 -.f� had lx'<:n un,k11Jl,.in� ··,.,ni,: qualil\ J''lll':.1111.'l' ,1;,_11i,til.', rnr my ()\\!l h�n1..: li (', i·h\111 lhh 1.'\ idi.!ll\�·- I ha,1..• 1<�·111�,1 th� , 1,·11 1h.11 .\h Corrin h.,J till: propcn,il� 1,1 1ai..c: 11 111><•11 hcr...:11 11, ..n�h1 till \,1( 1111!..,·· a:-. ,h...: JXl'l'ci, ...·d thcrn to h.:. I 0Ch1..'\·c her g...:nc1.tl 111K·l'h.·rc1K·c III matl\..'"r, ol 1111� lYJ'C' w,,uld l.':1u...1..· -.enou, 1.·Pnrcrn �1m�>n:-!�' ntlh:r ,1aff ;md ..:1..·na11d� \\ 11h lh.'1 ,urx,:-riur... l h.t\t: 1..·arht·r rcll"rrn.t to t.·,Huplaant, lud,:,,'"°ll m "riling h� \h Corrin tu Iler ,upcnor, al tli.· Hn,pi1al. B� 11a)· ol ,·,arnl'k. ,c,mc or 1h�,c incl ude:- Jui} 1991 - Ccwrc,p,mJc1ll:( tc..:..:i,.:J hy Nur,ing Adm111i�1m11rn1 from M·, Corrin c-ornrlaining ahouc the 1crisc a1m1"phcr<· m CSSD and that ,he \\et-. hc!ing , k1inu-..c<.I hy 1hc Chtirg� Nur-<. Siron� r.:-fl.!rL'n...:l' was mad� by M, CrnTin in thi, lcncr 10 ll\'r ,1a1c (1I h,-,,hh. This 11.1, foll,"«Xf h� fu11hcr l'orr.:,pnndenc.:c in :--.:member 191)1 "here M, C'orriu n>1nplaincd thac she "•'' hc111g 1i.:11mi"-'<I hr Rc:•i,t<'rcd \urs.c, m C'SSD /11:irch 199:? • \n I X page do<:umi:nt from M, ('C1n111 10 /\,,i,urnt f)ircc1,,r 11f Nu"ing. P \\ lklll. l\·h Cllm ll had ,,,mpl:uncd ,,r hcrng ··1crl>ally .thu.;.,J hy ,wff. 1ncquit} m ha rn,tcr,. nlllllK'I i n CSSD. l ad; of c.:,nnmuni..:atton. ill ddim:d e,pe<'IJtion,. har.i"rnent. an<l all<1,,•·. D,'\:cmh1:r 1')1)� • !\h Cornn wrote• tu I' \\'(wJ<I -.t:it1nu thill ,h� "as ""n.;crn..:d ,,1,.,11, hi, at1i1uJe lo produc1111t)·. Al Lhi, ,1agc. 1\b Corrin damll:c.l ,hl' had dc:,dopc-J ., m••·c- appropriate ,ys1.:m for run11ini: lht' CSSD. \1an.:h l<.J'Jy · Conc,pomlcn,c· fr o m M, Corrin 1n P Wood <il'mamling that P \\c.'lf t:('opcr.ite \1t1h her 1I � \\1sht'tl her g11c1ant�. rcga,ding the .1llnc11i,m 01· ,hift,. 1,1 b� rc,oh·cd. tvh1� JlJtJ., • A, a cnn:-.cqt11.:11t1.,' of a --�\\t..::uin� 1nL·1dcnt... �'1, Corrin k,1:;,xl :i �nc,an.:'-' {-1,g:ain-..t a �rie,·:inl'C �i1re;1dy lo<.lgl'<l a�ainsl hen and adv",·t1 1ha1 Iler soltdlor would 11': p,x:-cnt al 1h,· c.:onii.:r,·nn· . Thi, o,:c.:urrcd. h1.11 the ma11cr rc,nainrd unrc,ohl'd. \\ith che nn�lll;il t·nmplainam ,, i1hJrJ\\ in� ht:r gric,allf:\". I ha,c 1101 n:krrcd lo all 1�· th- incic.l,nt, r,u-...'(l h) hoth �h (\,rrin and M, Chirn1ii "hik M, (\,rnn '"" cmph1yed w11hi11 ih� CSSD ar,•:,. I am -.:ui,fic'tl. h<111c11.·r. thal :,.t- Cnuin·, pcri,'lf ul cmplll)lllcnl in lh" .m:a was punctuated h� rcgul�ff irn.·u.k·nh of ,onll i(.'l, Mt:-.pitinn, p>or \\<rl pc·rfnrmarn:..: and gcner..il d1,n.:μanJ l'<,1 <lin.:rlillll fnm1 "ll l1\.".rinr.... Th" h<!IKl\iour wa, n,>I left lllll'llWkcd hy 1hc 1:mpln)cr. (',1ed are nm11<.·111u, namplc, uf h<m and llhen 1h..- cmpl11�.:r .,ucmpt<·d lo fL',ohc ,nnic 111 lhl' conl11c1 111 wh1L·h M, Corrin v.a, 111\ohc,I. ;\ r,·,ullam theme from ;111 of1h,:-...! di......,·u,,inu, \\·a, that lht.· prohlcm wa, ...onlcorn: ..:-1"'-'· , 01her 1h,,n M, (011'1 11. i\l, Corrin \\',I\ l'\t:Jllu.1lly lr:rn,fcff c-<l l<> 1\1.-k in roc.ilre Al 1h,, ,13gc. l\\o l1111.'l'lla1 lrn:i<.11..•nt Kcp\U'h wc1\: kl(lgct.l \\ilh th(' Nur�,n� AdtlluHslration h,· 1lw c,-c uf Thca1rc. Hoth rclakcl to i11,·1ek:111, in,uh in� !\.h Currin. S�m1i; crn11plain1, '"':re 11lure 1.>f an ag�raq11ing than ;1 ";·iuu, m1turc, ho""."·� th1.· •�Jl\.' PI 1,:nnn:1n �\.flt't...'\"'-l'.(i \\COl lll j..,,uc!'<> ..,lh,.·h ;1, �,1, C<,nin·� ··qli c,11,u1in� t,r pri:-111...:-di1..atuHl <'l\kr�. tht...· p,,Jit..·y ,;,, t·h1.·1..·1'.mg d.111gt'rt,u, dn1�, ,111t1 lwr an.·u,:tl1<H1 ol un�1f1,; practH.,'1.' h,: :t H.t.!_μhtuc<l Nt11 �e :· .\h Cnrrin al,o t.:ompl,rnl�ll ol ;1 .. prok,..,.ou;d 111a!pr,1ll1<.:c pn)hkrn n:fotin� h• a ...,ur�'--"1n 1md ...1,.llill,:! her hd1d th:tl ht.• \\:t, inHthlxl rn un,1le pr :1,1ic.:c ;,nd dtd 110 1 adhere lo rrnpc-r pn>ill<'OI. (' ( 11,rm ·''"' ,1.i1cd that 1.:rh;,,,, llll" ,ur,:-��<'ll had a lno\\k-d:-c ck.·Jil'il... l'hcrc \\tn: ulh\!r ;1llq:,11it,ns rn� 1Lk h� !\I, Cornn \\h1bt cmplo,cd in Tht:;1111.; and 1hcy ,d.1h; (P ,..,...UL"!-- nf mi:-.'illll! ,lru�, i.:tl.'. ,\J;.iin \·h Con 111 v,.,1 , cuun'Cllc<I rcg.arc l1ng lwr hch;n ,our ,llll.l wa.s lran...k,n.·d tu ()uaJi1, A,�111·�mc:e I m a rx:nu.J of 11111c. -\1 a p.i111rnl.ir Work,hop. !he i'nll,"' ing p:inc-rn 111' hrha, iour a11nhu1�d ll• :\h (UJTltl \\;1-... lHlft..•<l·- l>i"1l1pt1,\! .mtl ucgau, ...• h''-4.�trd:,,. ,pca�l· , , .11M..l olhcr panjl.'ip.111t:-- at tim..:, 11i-.:pl:t)Cd n1.'�a11,c .ntitudc ll•\\anh '\!\l.'ral -..i:,,h,n, :�Hcrnph:Ll tt.1 di,puh.· ...p�al�,..._ on -.c,c..· ml t)\.;....·a,1<u1, Di.I 11ot p:1r1icipa1c in the pha1 m:1c-nl,1�) 1ir.i,11,al -..:,,io11. \\ hen ..,.,t..cd to. tn�d ltl (.h,pt1tt..· n, Ill'-''- "'''� Conipl:ii111 fr<,m :1 ,,)l.'at\1..:r re}!ardinc! her d1,111p1il•n amJ .111i1udc:·. lhL' 11,"pnal lldJ the ,1r,,11,; hdtcl lh:tl VI- (\,trill lhnufhl ,h� 11:1, ·""·a)' h.:ini; 1-.:r,tT111cd h; ,�hl'I ,,an 1111:mh.:r, Tu 1hi, mtl. .\1' C'11rn11 \\n'h.' 11um1.'h>u, kllL'r, hl hi.:r c111plo)l.'f' unth.:1 gt.·1-..:ral h..:; 1dinl,!, ,udl ,l� APti...1,� Pn,..:'-"'"' - \\ork Pt..1i:1...-·. C\:na1nl�. th.un ''''-"n it..-·\\mf .,If of ,\1, ("tirr in ·.., 1..·t11 rl.'.',p(>llll1.·n(i: 11 :1pp�;,ir, tlrn1 th1.: i:mpl,): ..;r', hd •d· \\ a, al.'...:ur�1 11..·. :"vh C\•siin. m tk·1 ,,triou, \\ 1 i11i.:n rc,pP11'.'l' ' h) '4Hll.: d:11nh anJ in hl.!r e1�nt.·r.d l'\1J,:nl'e hdon.: tht.· Commi......1011. d,,�� ,llh\\CJ' ,t•lllt.' PI lhL':--l'. \.'l;,1im,. hu1 in all in,1:.m'-c'.'. 1h��n: i... rn.·,�r an, ,�.._•p�Jlit1nn f1rnn h....1 1hat -.om� ,,f 1h� pl'<lhlcnt, m.,� � <>f l'H..'f tlV.. n mll�ini ( )n ::w.:h lll'Gt'\itin. \h ( ·,111 in \\,,ulJ ...t.H� th.11 ,he h.1d ll'k..',mt \\hHh.'H·t t.·omn1ent haJ hl�n c,m�plain\.."\I of 0.1, a ",it,J..i:'·. nr th:H 11 \.\a, ,imp!� ,onh.'Pll\,; ch.1.··:-,. faull. i:.; May . 1998 QUEENSLAND GOVERNMENT I DUSTRIAL GAZETTE 23 \I, y I U\ l..l"ll 1)111..X'h� of \;u, ..;(n� ,II th"' Hu�p!lal ...i1k.'c.� J CJ9-41 g�, c th1.: ll,U1,,\ inμ .... , \tkm: t·. \I, ru.kl'lt ,:Ill\ '"'"" Ille 11·,ron,,h, llll,·, of ,111 1·.nrollcd \'urs1· ;uiJ ,ir._ ..."l.·tl ,lut ihi, 1ctk -.:011ld irn: ludl! hoth pal 11;nt aml lHlll-tontm:I patient ,-.,,rk ihc l.111.:r 1, th,· •�11': ,� ,wrk "hi.:h had hern p.:rl,w111<·d t>y /11, c ,,ifin. l t�'ll t."\�H111na1ii,n qf \h Cornn':,. l.!t11J)lny 11K'lll lik,. !Vh Tu(.:i..Cll h.f\.:llili\,·"i f,,t.1 hr.xHI .trl.";1.., i,J \,"�'·'-·n\ \,hi,.:h hat.I ht'...�n a common lcaLm\; l,l l'\>lllj'l,t1 llt •1�,W bl \J, Cornn in the..· dilkn:nl a_n:.1, in \\hidt '� . had \\tlr��d ,11 ih, I 1<,,p,1;1! 111 >I, rud.cll , 11orJ, ·· I he ,umm�r; h1\!hl1�ht, M, ( 1.1rn11 ... ,\,Ol ll\llt)U ... p�1tt1.'fll of in�•rrm1pnalc lx·ha\Ulllf a11J J: ...1unc..-1umal "''r l.. h1..1nn :11 lh1..· \larka� H�i�· tlo,pi1al. It 11ro,·�, lhal �·1, C(lrrin v.a� tm.,N,.: l\, n�·1,.•t rhv r\.•,po1i...1htlili... �ol �11l\ p,..,111on \\ ithin mu,inp \Cr, ice, I h-.· I..\,·\ .ih.':i, 111 f•Hh;l'rn l'l..'la1in� IP h\.'r 1�1hmnanl..'.l' an<l �h;n·inur \\t..·rc not ..,,,n,lu,�,.... 11• ..,I!�· and L:"fft:L"t1, l" nt11 ,._. pr.1ttir1...• al the •'nnllh: d Nur.:,.t.: L..:-, d.·· \Ill.'' ,�·, ''-' '' m:.: 1hi, ,au,11i,111 thL' rmpln�L' ' dctcnninl'd lo tn,1itull' 11 llinm1hh,: d \\ pr� i"c.:lf(\fl!l,lll-...·l· pu�c...... fr,.- �I... Co11t11 around \la� 1995. \ 1... C nr I in in1t1 .i1!� H..·fu,L·ll tu pan1urah: in tlk· prr,....·c,,. pulling the mancr in th,: han,1... ,,1 h.:r ">l11,:11or i\f:,,. Cornn·..., rcfu..,,:11 lo p;.1111'-·1�11...:- l."Olttinuetl for ,on w d,1, ,. u11111 \,I, TtlL'"l' ll .11.h i�...-d h1.:r that th,l:iplin;,1ry �H.:tiun \\• ,,uld l--...: f;tl1-11 .,e::1111,, tk.·r ,1 "1.t..· did llOI '-''""ix·r.th.'. Jn order 1n c!-...�...,, t\:ts. <'orrin. a "l'• .'1.:i�1t J",...11 1110 h�t,! 1-x•c.�n matil'.' a,,1ilahk to fk'f. The po,ition \\il"I lhat of Poli�� 4-.;.upJ'XIII \ur-..c .\ fUP(t.'" "·" 'l'I i11 (ram hl ,u rrx)rt �h Corrin at lhi, ,1.1�\,·. I n,m lht.· t.'\ 1d'l·1h'c ...11rrr,..1rhhn,g lhh fk)ll\l. f t--:hl'\C th:.it rhl'.' t.·mplo�t.·1 . 1\.'l�'d 111 ., �l' IHJ1Jl1..· .111J ....upp,,nn 1..· 11tJlllllT {ow:inJ.., tv1' (1.Jrrin. I dctcct1.;d llom 1h1.· I,,"\ 1d\,•1)1.."\" ,l d\!�lr inh.�rhinn on th...- pan ol llk.' cmrlo�l'r tu �in· i\1, ( 'pn iu a "l;111 �o" u1 en,tlll' lh;.1 1 ,tu.; could fun�titin �1pp1 upri�1ld) \\ithm 1hc I ti -...p,t 11 \'II\ tfi.MIOh.. lll. l'h.i'\\" J •'I !h(· r• Pt:12'" \\a, 11nJ1.-'l'l:)),.c11 hl'l\\l'l'll May :incJ Augu"I or I\Jt.J� la1\\\'\t-r. :1 J.11lt1r� h• progr1.....,.., ,J11...1�1ctnr,I� <lurmc! 1h,... p.:ru.i<l kd th"-· ,.: niplo:l't (0 ir1,ln::it1.· Ph:1,1.• :? frt\lH Au�u..;.1 ln !\o\'l"llllx:I' J\)1J5, At lhC (:Od or \\1..'\.·ld� 111L"t..'l111�.... �I, Cnn m \\a, 1i.,nnalh t1«.hi�t.l nf l"-!r J"Khillnn \dlh rupit.•..., .,r 1\:k· , all! i)ll\ inn.itl(l)l h\' 11)� μ1,,.:n h) ht'I lm1'•"''·"" I) \I, I uch·n hd1<·, �d th.11 dmn.:al pl.1l1:tne111 for 'Vh Cornn ,,uliltl ix: ,n:ippn ;pnali.: :h ,hl· i.,a..., a,,l�,�t1 �, ..., hcin� ill) "un,afc pnu.·111ioncr". Jk:ornl 1h.11 11nll'. \\llh 11n m1h.·J i111pro,1..'l1k."nl Ill �1' Cornn·, \\O(" 1vr!i,1m;11h·,:. PJ)lH''" ,t\ailahk tu the: l'111plny1..·r "l.'.H' t"'<plPr1.·d. �'I, C<1rrin ....,.. ,·,,·011.all� 1..·11rnn.1h_•,I .mtf I du thlt 'flu:,11011 1h� llli:lJllll'r 1n ,,h1l'h 1111, \! \:(llfl('\I '" 1c·111is lll lh,· p,, .......,, ;1elop1c-d r>) till' lio,pn.,I. M, c.-·n n ,1a11·, that lhl· ,·n1pl� 1... l'I 11:ul l!l ,'lllt\.·l'r'I .,r he,\\ 111 c..'Oll1h 1l· 1 lhl' l)1m1ni...111..•1.I \Vt)l'I-. P,·rlon11.m,·1.· ph1�r:11m1�· SI►...· hdie,l..",1 th:11 \J.., f\ R\ �lll ( l)in...-cror nf '\m,111:.,':\ktlu,: :,I ·;,... \\�!! ii' !:.qual �-.mpl<lYllll'lll Li:11,un C>rlil.:.:r :ind .-\nti· ,lt,n1111n.1l1<•n I 1;,i,,,n 0111,-.:r II uh th<· liu,pllJI, diJ nrn un<l.:r"1,1nd the l,,.,,x..,, ..,Jk' "a ... h 1 t1nd�1 tdl ..· ,tnJ tk11 lh(' m1,;1hoilol1)gy <1dnpll'.d ,,a, ,k1i..1,·nt. \J.., (·,m·1n \\4.' Hl l(l -.onll' k·n�th Ill l.'\{lltun 10 the (\unmi,1o.11m 1ha1 'h"· l.u h1 r1..· ,,t lh-1..· �·111pid�t:1 h 1 adPpt an app1opnart..· '\.-rlrfl·;,1 ...:et' Jg_a111...1 ·,1,h1\,·h It, n·, 1c..·-., h\T ,tt11,111un hdd �·;ui-.,'d lwr "l' f 1ou� d1,ad"alll,1�c. I h\.·rc \\,1.., ..,rnrn: hh,:I\ 11\ lh1..· u1111n1c111\ rnad1.· h, �1' C,)1Tin in thi, 11..:.1rd. hu1 h�·, ,1.111,.•n1.:;1..., !.!Crt.·1alh t.lt..•....·t..· nllcJ ii11e1 �mtrlc:1tc anah,1, of '-"h•li-. ih:�11.k.·11\11..· tlh'1.1ri.,.'" \\l;kh ,hu;dd hl' adopl1..'<l m m,torn..:\·, ,111.:h :t.,. thi.... l f"11. lin""'' \'t. 1h.11 1h1, ,i.:1:. .1pp1,,: u.:h hi,ghfi�ht�d ,nmc ol 1hc J11'1it...' Uhit•, r.,..n, h� '"' t \\fllll I h..:11.: "'1.:Hlc.'d Ill OL· ,, (;(ll11rh.·h,; inah1lil� on ;\1:,. C,1rrln', p;ul "' ,l·.J! ,,i1il ""'ll'-'' .,, th�� f'l• :111� \\t:ll.'. Co1nplic.: att•d and dc! a ilcd .iu;il� ,,.. '1"-'rhli,J... �1 l-tHlllllt'!l '-4.'fl,1..• apprt,11.h to '1t..."klkl\\ kt.l!!in:.: and n;"'wl1hinc l'H•hkot,. .. .. ... I 1 1 11d...·r,1:nd 1h,· lo,, ol i:111ph1yflll'lll ha, t·au-.t.:d \1, C,1rrin �nuu, di,atl\ ,m!:J:'.'t' f k1 'l.1bmi,,1n11, ,urrount.hn� 1h;..• impaL'I of thi, e\'cn1 upon lM..·rhl· ,!Iii. h....·1 l!k· ,1� k and h1.·r h, 1pt..·:--- inr ,h,__. hiturc \\1..•n·. f hclN:,.:. gcnun'k:. fl:i,I 1 1•d1,· -. ,·cl lh,11 lhc Hn,pllal 11,,d a,·tctl 111t,•mpc1;l1d) 11r u11lairl) t,manl, h,:r I �,oult.l .lt1,�n1rt !(l f\.•dr,•,.., 1h� ...,tui1tiun a, h,:,1 I OJUltl u1ili,111g lhc 1d'l' \ .u u pn;, i,tt)fh 1H llK· l.\.'l-!l\l:11u111 .. l<q,r,11ahl\ lnr .\I, C1111 m. 1111, 1, nol th,: ca,e. II :1m1hinf, the llo,pi1al \1.4.•nt 11' ''"11'1\.:',h.a t \."\lrat,rJi;.,.1t, krn!llh to fad)it:uc..• t�cr l'i\lKcrn,. rill' t1th.pllal l'lld111\·l! �\,·ar, ,,I l·n111111�1\d t'(�lllplaHlh fn.1m ilOd a!!�lll�t �I, Co1Tm lu �•••d l,11111. I hdi�'l' 1ha1 the l lo,p11al addrc,"'tf Lh..-,.., C<lllc\!rn, a, C\fXUlll"l"I) ;m.l .111,111 "' 1>1...,,1hk Co1Ntkr.1hk cotNlh.111011. n1un-..:llini,: .,nd :id, 11..,· '' i.h �·.i,\!li to M:-. ( 'pn m hut. ;n 1ht.! 1:ntl. a formal pnxl.',, \A.a.., ,,·4uu<·d tu Ix· un.fut.1!.t-11 111 proper!; addrc,, 1h..:-..- c111x:crn,. \\'hal M, C orrin mi,u,,,� for inappr.,rria1,· arplii:m1,1n of the Dimimshccl \\ url. Pcrlilrmarlt."C pn,gr�Hnme. I ...a\, ,,, an aucmpt h� thl..! ...·mph,�cr not '° �. ht:il\�•h,llKkd" 1011,,rd, !'.1' Cornn hut to ,IIIC!ll()I to ><.'11,itt,cl� )<.:I pmf..,"iun.ill; lkal II ilh :, particular ,cl Clf .:1rn1<1htan<:�,. Whit" :VI, C'i>rrin may 11:1\� tx:�n lx:11cr ,..,n..:d utili,111� 1hc· ,..,n iL·e, of an ;.uhocall' llurtnf ttk: hcarinf Cdnt.1 I at·i:cpt llt.!r l'ommcn1Jr,: that her linancc!> \\ou lJ not pcrmi1 1h1,J. from 111y 11ew 11 111>11hl nt1t ha,� .iltaetl lh� ou1.:om<.: Thi, i!'-. unftwlunatdy. :in O\'CJ'\\ hdmin� \.'�!',(' nf an ..:mplnyn� who :-.impl� «a, 1111;,l,lc 10 lt111c11011 appn,pria1d, in 1h,, p:1n 1Cul,u "''r'- em·irnnn11.·nt. I c·an find 11<' n ilknn: thm lhc cmpln)Cl' ached 111:ippn,pn:11c11 ,,r unf,1id>. Th.:refllrc. ,, �ain,1 chi, hac:�gn>tincJ. I ,11n ,:it,,licd 1h:1t the crnpl<>)<.:r h :i , no1 lv�arlk.-d the di,rni,'411 pnni,ttm, of lht.· :\1.'I 1n tkt.:1lhng 10 Lc..·nHinat� lh� "-'r' ic·<!, ,,r M, Con in. M, (nrrin "a' aflorded natural Ju,11.:c an,1 :ill 111,, pro1cc1irn1' prol'id\!cJ hy 1ht: Lq!islatirni. I dhmi" 1hc application. D.A. SWAI-; .\l r V Kern,. Y.ilh him l\1r I' l 'n·11 on tx:hall of()ucc-11,lwtd lk,tllh. ########11#/t#####ll################lt#####Mt########lt#lf#ll!l##U -- 2 of 2 --