David Jones (Australia) Pty Limited. Queensland Division v Barbara Anne Mason [1995] QIRC 247 (1995) 149 QGIG 931

930 Q UEE SL A ND GOVERNMENT IND S TR lAL GAZETTE [2 1 July . 1995 2 1 Ju ly, l 995J QUEENSL AN D GOVER 1~ Ei T I D STRIAL GAZETTE 93 1 <.>l l I.\,SI ,\;-.; I) !Nill I<., I RI,\ I RI I.A I IONS C0\.1 1'- l l '.-> \ ION l11.l11,1ne1I R, h11m11.,. lu I 99IJ ,. 106 - ,1pp lil.:a11on fo r c"'I~ , •1111 - ,,pph..-,1111111 for ..-,,,1, l>:11 ,d .h>nc, (1\u qralo,11 1'1~ l.1111 i1cu. ()111:.:n,l:mJ Di, 1,iun .\ Ni l ll.1rh,1rJ 1\11111.: :',1,Nlll I \11 flJ:: t1/ I IJIJ_IJ l O\ IMJS\JONJ R NI ' I I J R Ill JulJ 199.- \rph, .11 ion li ,r ( "'" Rcfcrcncc It> t'<1,.: I.a \\ · Ai b i1, .11.: tl \ l ,111cr \ppli .;11 1011 li,r ( ·u,1, C,r,m 1cJ Dl·CI SIO~ In Ill~ tlu:1,u,n J.,i.·u I<, lchru.11~ 19 111. I lt,1cd :n \ fard1 l•)'J4 to hc;u· , 11 h111i,,ion, conccn1 111g lhc al\a rding nf c,,,1, in rc,pce1 In rhi-.,ppli..:.1111111 I hat J.11c '"" , at.:.i teu 1,,11,m inμ ,111 arrcul l< • I It, J lo1111u r. the l'rt',)<lt.:nl. ag.1i1ht the <lt.:Chlllll 111, I 101111111 h;mJe,1chmn ,1juUJ!lllCnt d i~llll\stlll! an aJl pCal 1111 1 J Dc..-cmt,.,,,r I 99~ D.1, 1d lone, I \u,1r,1h,1) l't~ I 1miteJ ( D.1, 1J .lunc,) ,uthc4u.:11tl~ ,ough l t lw 1 thi, ,<pp lic:111011 lu r co.,i- he re-lis1c.:d I hi, hca nn,: "in 1da1io111t11h1~ m:utcr I III c1111,e11 1c1ic-c purr o,c, J " ill icier In 1b.: ~urrt.: 11 1 numhe n n,!! , ,f the :\t·t. \c,.:11011 I Ut, 11 .1, pn:1 inu,I) ,,.:cunn K-t anJ p1 i,1r 1,1 1h.,1 ,,dhlll !UK -;n tiun :;oo "·" rre\11111,I) ":lll(lll ,-- ,mJ p1111r Ill lhJI wt:tion 11 11 I he• ,:11111,.:nt, of e,tch sccl iPn li,r lhc purpo,c, 11 1 lhh 111,lllt.:r 1, 1Jcntie.1I I{ \\ ',1ll.c•1 l,1r D ,I\ iJ Jone, ,ub1n11 1.:d· 1h.: \.:t ea.tbkJ the ( ,,mm,"11111 It• •"' ,uJ <'<"h 11nJ<.:r t.:llh cr , 111/1 ur, .<(l!I. I hat hoth ,c·c 11 011, .1n: C\C·lu,I\ c• ;1nu do not .lq,cntl .,u ... ,,..,h otl11,,;.r l',bl' l.111 ,upponcd the :m .11J111g 01 ~n,t,, 111 , C\,!li,111, or 111,1111111, apphl,llion, lhL· d,l.'h1on ,,1 111<: ( <•llllllb,ion ,tatcJ th,11 th,.: c, iJc11ct.: ,,r B \l ,N,n 111 \ 1lu.ld) ''·" 11111 crctl,hlc in reg.ml to> 1h.: ( R \. \ n1c1dc111 and thJ t a ,111 1~ haJ h.:t.: n ci 111 c11c tcu lu cm er up "h, 11 haJ th.. ~ urcd th,.: Jcci., iu11 , tmt.:<l 1ha1 H .\ 1:i~nn had J i,rCf,tr<lc J ·i-1r11lll<ll1, Imm ;i ,,.:11ior offker ,111.t tlw ,1pplicJ111 ,houlJ lhl\'1.' l.n,111n lhJI tin, \\hen r,1111hmcd \\1th thi: illc[! ,t l cn.:J11 d i ed '"iulJ r,"uli 111 he, .1ppli~.1t1011 hdnμ 1111,uc·cc•,,lil t ,'\,.:,,,rdingh 1hc .t[ph\.,tllon "·'' fri,(110•1~ or , ...·,.ui,,u, rc;N111.1hk olkr~ \\CIC m;id,: h) D,I\ 1tl Jone, 1t1 ,crrlc the maucr \ ,crh,11 ai:r,•c111cn1 "•'' re,,d1.:J on 4 I ehniar) 199, lh.: ;1pr1J, .1111 r.:nq· .:J on 1hc a1:1r••L· 111 .:nt .,nJ mall,· a co u 11ll: r ol l~r ,11' l1i~h,1 p1,,porthllh ,1hrd1 ,,a, l'lacc,pt,1hk to l>,1, ill lone, I l a, ,d l,111 L·, had inl' urrcd in e\c·c" of S 100.0 00 111 k!!al ~•hh ,lion,.: .1, 1,dl a, <:1hb fo r .111 J~Cl'l tu app,·,,r. in .1dJ1tl(ln 111 1h.: t:n,.: l \p.:nd..:J h) 111r 1..cr, ,,r the (. u111pan~ ,ind ,1,1, .: 11 111 lt:d to rc,11\ •·r "lilll' of th..: cn,t, rdi:rcn.:c "J" 111JJt.: tu a numhcr ol llc,1>1011, rclaung 11 1 11c ,l\\,t rJ111g ol· C<hh . B \ l <1M111·, ,uhmi,,ion~ of rcl..:1.mc" 01 """ "e111 to 1h, fi I IIO\\ Ill!,! - that ,h.: \\3, 11:nnmatc<l un 9 l),·c·cmbcr J 111)'.! JnJ h.l\ 111,.. rcg.,rJ 111 1h.: f;1c1 thJt th.: appltc,1ti11n Jnr cn,t, "•" h.:mg hc,m.l 1111 15 June 1995. 111.·u rl~ ,i , 111 0 11 1h, a lkr 1hc l,,sl appea l d c1crn11 n;111, 111 . tit•· lime pcnuJ ,huuld \\orf.. agJi11,1 an) nrJcr for~'"" thm the app licnt io11 was nu l Ii i, n lnu, or ,·c, ,11io 11, an<l lhal ,h, ),!ennind) \\.11110:J rc11hta1c111e111 1ha1 shc lx: lic, cd 1h e 111a11.-r h:.iJ ,c uk u hut 1h.11 th e cmplo) er haJ rcfu-.cd tu ,1gn ., fu11hcr JccJ nl ,cnkmcm \\h1d1 h,,d hcrn dc h, crcu to 11. rc:h:rcncc: \\ J.., 1n1.tt.h.~ tn ,ont..: J,Jlc(;t~ ul c, 1Jc.:nu.: th,tt Jn.: nut pcrn nc 11t for the p11rp o,c o f dc1crmi n 1nl' c·o,1,. 1111, ..-a!><: n,dl \\J, length~ and np,:n,l\c l>a, r.J lnnc, ha1c a;..,c,wJ 1hc1r le!!,11 Cthb a1 ~ I 00,000. ll m,c, er. " r r11pn 1t io11 n l the C<1'1' \\ <.: re a, ,I n:,u h of :1 appca l, lo I Ii, J l, 111o u r. thc P r,·,1dc111 . <•n.: h) l>.1, rd .lone, JllJ 2 I>) lhc :.tpplKar~I II "un li11111 11 :1t e th.11 the ma ucr "a" 11<11 ,ct1 k:d a, on the ,,J, i~..- l,!l' .:n It• me ,II t hc h.:Jnng II Jp(l<:ar- 1h,11 al "'''-' ,l.lj!<.: pr-,1r In lhc 111 :illcr prncccd in g IP hcaring. 1h c pa,11" ci 1hc1 had or 11c rc c h1,c to reaching agrccm.:nr. ho""' er. ,udi ,l f:!recmcnt nut liuall) u111wmmat.:J I Jt.h p,111) ha, thcrr 11\\11 ,,r,a111 •" lo "h' 1hi, J1d 1:01 u,uir I ho: a ll il ud , 11 1' 1h 1,; C t1 111111 1,,io11 1111 app hcal ion li •r rn~ t, "a' dcah \\ uh h) 1h, I lo11011r. 1h.: l'rc,iJcut. 111 ( '""'"'"'' 1 f),11<1 ( 11 11,r,1 1 ( 14 -t (,)( , I( 1 lilJ .x I ) Il l <Ill ,1pp.:. 1I a;,l,1111,1 1h,· I11dthln,1l t ·,m11111,,io11 li1r 1h.: ,J\\arJ 111μ 01\:,i-1~. · I h.:-..: l,1w, illu,1r.i11: 111..: 11111 ~ ,1an<l1111,: ph1 ,i-oph~ of tile l 11 tlu,1rial ( ' n 111 111i,"0 11 1h,11 i 11 1ht.: ab,cnt:c u l' In , nln u, or , 0.:\,1tio11, ~ppl!,·a1ron or other cir,11ni--1an,c, th.il arc .chnornal ~,,,i- ",11 rhll l>e a" irdcJ 111 th.: tr,1,htillnJI l..111u, ol 111all.:r "11hm the jurisdil-1 in 11 o l Ili c l 11 d11, 1rial C1111111 1i "io11. I l, , \\c 1c r !here i, J <l1,crc111111 10 I'<: c\l·r,1wd .Uld ,uch d"crc1111n .:an1101 he lt:rrcrcJ 111 q1ch a ,,a~ that, 11 1 pract1c.il 11: nn,. dcn1c•, its chara rwr a, a d 1>cr.:1 io11. Wh o.: rc • 11c um,H11 1cc" that ,all proper!~ bc J.:,cribc,I .1, :1h11,1m1JI ,,111 b..- 1Ju11rlicJ m a c.i-, .inJ 1t \\11111<.l c.w,c ,cr111 u~ in.1t2'111: c 1f .o,i- ,, cro.: 1101 :l\1,1rdc d 11 ,1ou kl 11111 dn , io lcn<.:c 1,11h c s,.: genera l p, in, iplc, 11' an . 11 1,1 rd ot' rt"l' 1, l! ' 1cn. It ,hnulJ ho\\.:, er he cmph,hi,.:J that the c1ru1111,1J1h.•-,, 11w,1 he :-ll! llllicanl l~ Ol ll of lht.! onlin ar ) b cli 111· lh ,: g,'llt.:r:11 rn lc i, J.:pa n cd Imm. It i, rcal1_1 thl' ra111111alc 01'1hc ca,c, 1,hcrc wsb h:I\ c bc,·n :t\\JrJ.:J 1hat ,11ch ,irctmhtan«, h,I\ c "••11 abk 111 h.: idcn ri licd ... I It, I lt111our 111 1he ,,1111c Jc~1"on ,tlsu ,1,11 cd lklurc c1•1hid~rm,! \\hc1hcr 1'1l lnJ i-1nal ( un1m1,,1,.o·, c,c , losC 111 uiscrc 11 on should he d1,11, rh.:d •d c r.:nt:<· ,houlll he mac.k LO a JlllSS:lfC Ill hi , d,·ci,i,)ll /(1 99'.,) I P ()(i l (i 19') ,thoul rc111,taicmcn1 pro~.:cJing, 111:: p.1,,;ag~ d,>c, 1101 mn•hc a dcp u11 11 1c Imm the p ri nc1plc Lh,ll has g..: ncr a ll~ applied 111 the lndu, rrial C'n1111n"~1nn l,.:c.iu,c it rccogni,c, that the ,wrli,c of -- 1 of 2 -- 932 QUEENSLA D GOVERNMEl\TT I D US TRIAL G AZE TTE j:! I J ll Iy. 1995 the J1,1.:rctio11 ,h.,11IJ co111i 11uc 111 he ··carcl'lllly gu anlcd .. a nJ ,111 ·"'an! ,,r t1'-'' 111 rcm,t.,tcmcnt pr<'cccdmg, ,houl<l h~ n.:,n, cd fn r .. th o,c .: a,c:; 11 hich lkm and 1h ~t , ulh an a"MJ he mudc 111 tnc 1111.:rc,1, ul Ju,ti<"< and 1;1imc" oct11cen the p.11t1cs .. :-,; ,, 11 cthc k ,~ 11 dnc, niak.: the rn nH th,ll Mllll C rc instat ..:mc•11 1 ca,e ~ h~ rca-..,n 111 thc prou.:<lura! ,1cp, in\l>h eJ and their n,llurc. kngth and 1·1 >1npl c ,11~ h,1, c r,1ther ;;111 a"••~ Imm t he i,lc.1! ,,1 inc,pcn,i, e Jispute ro.: " ,l11 1ion I hcrc 111.i~ he ·;omc ..:.i~e, \\hicn: at t h, .::ml nt' the d,1~ II can he ,-.een that .s p,111~ h,1, ,1c1eJ unf, 11 1I~. 11nrca,01i.1h l~ 111 irnprop..:rl) in nr in tin: cnursc 11 1 pur,u111g ,,r r.:,i,1111g ,u~h rclio:I ,mJ thJt tho,c acw,n, 11erc ,., 1mj11,1 iliahk: 1ha1 the r rucccd1ng~ haw ,,nrkcd .,, ,111 art ot uppre--.1nn 1,, tb: other ,1,k II i.:u.:, Jlmn,t 111tlwu1 -..a~ 111μ that c,1,e, 11hc 11.: ,uch II li nd111 g .: nul<l pmpcrl~ h.: made \\t ll bi.: r;1rc .md "oulJ hJ,i.: 111 lit the 1k,u1p1mn fri"•lnu,. , c,a111,u, or n1 h en\l,c ,,hnn nna l I hi.: mcri.: l,11:\ th,11 ,1 r,,n i f,111, tu ,11cc1.....:J ll(>llld r..: 1,11 n:lll\l\ ed lr.1111 ,11,, kind .. r C,lS<.' ,111 tl \\OUl<l he Im frnlll ,ulti,,ct.t 111 t,,unJ .,n arr111ni.:nl lor llhh '\11 one "uh ,1 rca,rnrnhli ;irg.u,1hlc ea,..: ncctl b.: <le1 ..:r n:d I I om prnc c.:d111;; b~ li:,ir ot tl1c .-,n,1.:'-! 1cncc, ,,I "" ,1, unk,, ,rnnc ahm,m1al 1111la1r ,1,pc cl c111c r, ,mo 1hc n •nducl 11 1 1hc p111ccc d 111 ~,. I he prindpk '-!ll<•t.:J .shn,c cn,urc, th" ·· j11tl 1ct al/ 111d 1.: ial 111 m11t1rc . the 111a11er 11 en1 tn appe,1I on , ,,cl,1,ion, ,mJ the ,1pplican1 , ought tn he rcprc,cntcd h~ a hJm,;1cr ,1ou ld ha,·c kd 10 111, ccrt1lic,11wn un<l cr ,. 106 that II \\a, 111 the 1111cre,ts of 1u,11ce 1h;11 counsel. ~,li1;11or nr agent wa., he,ml. I he (. ,,mnu"il•II i, ,ati, ticd 1h.1l 1h c prim.1r~ pnrpo,c of II \1,1'<> tl 111 111a ll } \\,1' 111 , ...-c~ rc111,1,11cmc111 10 her pre, 1u11, P'"iuon 11111 if lh,11 i'ailc<l tn i.:,cn t11 ,1 1c. c,1111 1,c11,,1ti1>11 h>r \\rt1 n,dltl di,m1,,al 1n tlt,11 .:,t,nt the ••rrli..:Jllt>O. in thc ( ,,1111111"11>11 ,- \ IC\\ . \\a, not l'rt \ n1ou , ~1r ,·~,a1itn1, ·1hi.: t P llltn1> ,11>11 , , abo nl the h..: l1 c l th,tt II M,,...,111 . in hc1 1i1,n m11,d l·nn-,Jcr-. ,he J1d 11111 111111111Ja1c I I l,1rrb .1 ltl111t11.!h clea1 I~ 1>11 the ,:\ldcncc ,l\ ,nl,1hlc t,> thi.: (.111111111,"'" ' thi, \\,1, lnund h> h,l\c ,1,nm,·t.l 1-1 a ,1111il,1r ,c111 there""' a <l ifli: rc1u:e in \l C \\s hd\\ecn II " •""n ,UlJ ,1 numhcr ol "i111c,:.c, 1,,r ll," 1d Jone, "h1d1 ,, 11111 111 K11 11111 m11 111 d,,..ni--..,11 ,a,c, "ltc·re purtic, sc.: 1n c itle111, and ,1.11cm..:11h thn•u,!h ,li1krc111 ")"' IIJ<l 1h.:,.: b,:.:n 1lw 1111!~ ._ , ,11,idc r,1111111 , 110 j11, 11l i ca1 i1111 n11 11l d e ,1, 1 fn r al\ard 11 1!,! co, t, ,1ga i11~1 II \ l .1,1•11 h.l\ i11!,! r..:::,1rJ 10 ( nmm",ull1 pnm:iplc, J' 0111l111cd b~ I Ii, 1lnnnur 111 till' , ,i:,c r..:krreJ 111 herc111 11<,ne, ,·r. 11 11,i-. 111u111! b~ th.: C11111mt,'i1tll th,11 II \I J,.,n. h• ,url"•fl her''""· co11,11c1ed ,1 ,11'1'~ nit 1i \' I ludd, 11i1 h n:g;1rc.J 11, 1hc ( H \ \ 111u<lc111. \, ,1 rc,.ih 1>f 1h,, 1h,: hl'ann,: ,,f the m,tller ""' ,:~tt·nd..:J ,ign1 1i..:a111l~ h idct1l.C 11 ,i- calkd b~ hn th panic, 1hn111gh .1 i,11111ha 111" rne--c, on l!l< 111uJu11 ,111J th, ,1;;1111:,.intl~ '-,icnJ.:J 1h c hc, 11 t ill! 111 the ca,e. I c,tirn,111.: the ,1cld 11 11111 al hc,1r ini; 11 111..: 111 he 1n th.: , 1rn111~ ,,t':; JJ" i11 .1dtl11io11 j, 1h, 1i111,· lor 1h1, 1.:0,1, hearing 1lll',c addi1i,111ul 11.i~~ nl' hca nn ~ ncr..: a t.l i 1c<l r..:, uh ,,t ll. \\ 1,on p.1rs11m;, ha dJ11n 11: .111 ,,nl,ur. u111e.1-;oi1.1hk ,,r 1n1rmixr l\J) (i...:. a r,: , uh ol the conc.:11 ..: tc ,I ,101~) I hts \\ ,1, 11 n.1u~1i tkd. not n 11, !.',!, . •wd 10 1h.11 c,1e11t 11,1, in, ,,h,u, and ,c , .1111111, . I 1-ehn<.: a ,t.i1.:111-· 11 1 h~ I 1"h .I 111 \cm11,111 r lfa////r11., (( 11/ llt ) l .lK 85 7) 1, ,11'1"''"" 11hcn: h, ,1,11cd "In ,11dcr 11, hrmg ;i ,.i-, "i1h111 the dc,a1ptwn" (,, r tri, nlo u, and \C\Jt1,>1,, "111, n,,t ,ulii,1cnt mcn:1~ Ill ,.1~ tl·,11 the pla11111II h,t, tl<' eau,..: 1)1' ac1i,>11 11 n,11, 1 ar p..:;11 th, 11 In , ,1lkgc d e.tuw n t ,td •<>ll 1, ,n, \\h;ch. ,,n the i'J<..'- uf tl. " deJrl~ one \\h1d1 r.11 1c,h11 11 ahk pcr,11 11 e111 1h! tr..:.n a~ lw11.1 liJc. and ,·,lll ti.:nJ 1h,1t he l•,1J .1 .:m:,,111..:c 11h:1.h hl' \\J' icn111!c,l 11, t>nm.- hcli>n.: the ( ,,un. 01 i:1111r,c H " ,11111.: .,11011 111 lli.:gr..:c .. 11 1 thc,..: ..:irc11111,1.i11.:...-, ,o,ts '"II he ,11,,1rJc<l under , . _;0(1 111 r..:,pc,1 11 1' the ml<i iu un,d l1c· ari ng timc. 11 ,td the da im 11n1 l,1lk11 ,,11h111 1hc ,.:or..: 1,1, 3110. I """'J hJ,c a:1,m.itl\..-l) ,t\\JrJcJ ''"\' 1111 1cprc ,c111a1i,,n under ~- I (l(i ha, 111 g rq:a rd lCl 1hc .1h11111rn ,ll ,1r,1111.,ta•tl~' 11 thh c,1,c. 111:: l,KI lhJt the 111.111,:r \\,1, 411,i-1 • I agree II ith the ,uhmi~,1011 ol R Wal l. er lur Da, 1J .lone, 1h-.11 th, ( n n11n1, sion 1, clllf'll\\crcd 10 ,l\,,1rd c,"1' umkr s. 1116 <>r > .,oo ,111tl 1hat thc '"" ,c,;tinn, arc mu111all} e , clu,i , c B. \la , nn ,11t11n111c.:t.l that cn,1, should 111>t h..: a"ard1..-<l ha, ing rq!Jrtl tu the tld,11 "J11ch ha, n c1..-u rrcJ sinl.: tl1.: ,1rpcal dcnswn and ~incc th<.: J is rn issal ,iccurrcd I llc lllJIICr 1, a, li,tcd for C.:11'I~ hcurin:'. in \l arch la,t ~c.1r. rh 1, ,,a, a<lioumc<l li1llo\\i11~ the h•Ji.:menl of an appc,11 and "a , rc-lt,1eJ Jlicr the appc.il ""' tlctenmne1f II 11,1 , 11111 1hc fauh ,,f D:i, iJ Jo ne, 1h.it 1h e dcl,1~ uccurrctl and t he, ,huuld 111>1 he prc_1ud1ccd h) thc dda~ lor r cco, er~ ol .:,,,.._ In rd,11io11 tu the app!tc.1IH>t1 g e111:rn ll ~. the <lci,1) in linali,,11 i1111 wa, c,1u,cd partl~ hy a 11umhc1 111' Jppc,1I, af,1111'1 rul111g., ul 1hc ( 111111111,,um ,111J lhc lcll!,!th~ c ,,dcm·..: . \\ 1111,1 f)a\ ,d .1 ..11..:, ha , c incurrc·d ~uh,w1111al cu~t, ddi:ndmg 1he apphca\11\11. the dcc1,ion II> ha, e legal rcpre,cnt,1 11\ c, 111 thc ("1,1111111~,1011 a, \\CII a, an .igcnt h> rcpr..:,..:111 them "·' ' a tlcci,inn thal th e) 1110k and one for "hich the~ "ill ha, c 11 1 gcnera ll~ hear 1he u>,b In .1ddit11m ,uh,1anti.tl ._,o,b \\IIUIJ ha, c 1->ccn mcum:d durin~ 1h.: ,1ppcal pro c.:,-; and that i, nm a 111ullcr ll,r m~ ,,,11:;idcr ,11ion In dealing \\'ilh th e ques111 111 a, 10 the olli:~ made and then 11011• anept.mcc and pur~uancc nl pmcceding, amoun1ing 111 a fr" nlou, .md ,c\illtou, applic,1tion. o.:uch p:n1) ,u h 111111eJ that 11 "·" the lauh or thc ,11her in 11 01 coming l<• a rc,htlllilhlc ,c11k:111ent . On the int.>nn, 11 in11 :I\ .111.thh.: Ill me. I ,1111 unahlc IO ri:,1d1 ,1 c,, ndu"on 1h,11 it wa, so le I~ 1111.: r,,ull oi ll 7'1 awn that ~e 11lc111c111 "·L' 1101 al hie, cd ,111d thdl ~he , h,,uld hc.ir thc co,t, nf 1h..: 1111:il pr<1lC<.:d111g, \, ,1a1cd for re..1,-.l!I, e.1rlier ..-,r,,11,cd. I pmp11,,: h> ,l\,,1rJ co,h ln r the .1tld11 111 nal h..:anng 11111e and the co,1 he,1rtt11! .iga111,t II \l a,nn. Ill jn :1111m11ll 1,r '\l 1JI(, ', uch Jlll<l\1111 i, ra,..-..1 1111 the \1 ,1gi:-,tr:itc Court R,llc. 1hc c,, ,1 ,chedulc 11l11eh ha, 1,._,en u,cd pre, i11u,I~ hJ this ( ommi,,-iun lpp,·cnwtc c., \1 r R ,\ W.,l~cr IM 1hc Rc1ailt:rs· ,h,ndation nl ()uccn,l,,nd 1111111.:d. l'nion 11! l mpl,,)•:r, 1111 behalf ul 1),1\id Jone, l'\u,1ralml 1'1 ~ I 11m1e<l Op.:r.111,.: l>Jte· --,: \ I >cc 1,11>11 ( ,,,ts 2 1 July, l 995 J Qll EE. SLA io GOV ER 'MEI T INDUST RI AL GAZETI'E 933 -- 2 of 2 --