Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
Authorised Version
i
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
TABLE OF PROVISIONS
Section Page
PART 1—PRELIMINARY 1
1 Purpose 1
2 Commencement 1
3 Definitions 2
PART 2—THE FIRE SERVICES LEVY MONITOR 6
4 Establishment of office of the Fire Services Levy Monitor 6
5 Independence of the Monitor 6
6 Functions of the Monitor 7
7 Powers of the Monitor 9
8 Appointment of Fire Services Levy Monitor 9
9 Appointment of Deputy Fire Services Monitor 10
10 Cessation of office 11
11 Removal from office 11
12 Effect of vacancy in office of the Monitor 12
13 Power of delegation 12
14 Staff 13
15 Consultants 13
16 Immunity 13
17 Secrecy 14
PART 3—MONITORING POWERS 16
18 Power to obtain information and documents to monitor
compliance 16
19 Power to obtain information, documents and evidence 17
20 Powers in relation to documents 19
21 Copies of seized documents 20
22 Retention and return of seized documents 20
23 Magistrates' Court may extend 3 month period 20
24 Service of documents 21
25 Information sharing 22
-- 1 of 96 --
Section Page
ii
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
PART 4—PRICE EXPLOITATION AND FALSE,
MISLEADING AND DECEPTIVE PRACTICES 25
Division 1—Price exploitation 25
26 Price exploitation in relation to the fire services levy reform 25
27 Price exploitation guidelines 26
28 Monitor may issue notice to insurance company for a
contravention of section 26 26
29 Monitor may give notice to aid prevention of price
exploitation 27
30 Monitor may monitor prices 28
Division 2—Prohibited conduct 29
31 Prohibition on conduct falsely representing or misleading or
deceiving 29
Division 3—Pecuniary penalties 29
32 Pecuniary penalty for contravention of penalty provision 29
33 Defence to proceedings under section 32 relating to a
contravention of section 31 31
34 What happens if substantially the same conduct is a
contravention of section 31 and is an offence? 32
35 Conduct contravening more than one pecuniary penalty
provision 33
36 Civil evidence and procedure rules for pecuniary penalty
order 34
37 Evidence given in civil proceedings not admissible in
criminal proceedings 34
38 State of mind 34
39 Pecuniary penalty to be paid into Consolidated Fund 35
PART 5—CODES OF PRACTICE 36
40 Preparation of draft code of practice by the Monitor 36
41 Consideration of draft code of practice 36
42 Prescribing codes of practice 36
43 Offence to breach code of practice 37
PART 6—FIRE SERVICE LEVY DISPUTES 38
44 Making a fire services levy dispute complaint 38
45 Conciliation and mediation 38
46 Powers of the Director in relation to certain proceedings 39
47 Proceedings and costs 39
-- 2 of 96 --
Section Page
iii
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
PART 7—INSPECTION POWERS 42
Division 1—Inspectors 42
48 Appointment of inspectors 42
49 Inspector's identification 42
50 Production of identification 42
Division 2—Requirements to produce information 43
51 Inspector may seek court order 43
52 Inspection of documents under court order 43
53 Notification of execution of court order 44
Division 3—Entry and search of premises with consent 45
54 Entry and search with consent 45
55 Notice before entry and search 46
56 Acknowledgement of consent to entry and search 46
Division 4—Entry and search of premises with warrant 48
57 Search warrants 48
58 Form and content of search warrants 48
59 Announcement before entry 50
60 Details of warrant to be given to occupier 50
61 Seizure of things not mentioned in the warrant 51
Division 5—Documents 51
62 Copies of seized documents 51
63 Retention and return of seized documents or things 52
64 Magistrates' Court may extend 3 month period 52
Division 6—Offences 53
65 Refusal or failure to comply with requirement 53
66 Protection against self-incrimination 54
67 Offence to give false or misleading information 54
68 Offence to hinder or obstruct inspector 55
69 Offence to impersonate inspector 55
Division 7—Miscellaneous 55
70 Entry to be reported to the Monitor 55
71 Requirement to assist inspector during entry 55
72 Register of exercise of powers of entry 56
73 Complaints 56
74 Service of documents 56
75 Confidentiality 57
-- 3 of 96 --
Section Page
iv
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
PART 8—REMEDIES AND LEGAL PROCEEDINGS 58
Division 1—Substantiation notices 58
76 Monitor may require claim to be substantiated 58
77 Extending period for complying with substantiation notice 60
78 Compliance with a substantiation notice 61
79 False or misleading information 61
Division 2—Compensation orders 62
80 Compensation order on application of injured person or the
Monitor 62
81 Order to redress loss or damage suffered by non-party
consumers 63
82 Determining whether to make an order under section 81(1) 64
83 When is a non-party consumer bound by an order under
section 81 65
84 What kinds of orders can be made? 65
85 Power of court to make orders 67
86 Interaction with Divisions 1 and 3 67
Division 3—General 67
87 Prosecutions of offences 67
88 Who can bring proceedings for offences? 67
89 Contraventions by bodies corporate 68
90 Conduct by officers, employees or agents 68
91 Interpretation 71
92 Undertakings 71
93 Copy of undertaking 72
94 Register of undertakings 73
95 Injunctions to restrain conduct 73
96 Injunctions to do an act or thing 74
97 Interim injunctions 76
98 Power to rescind or vary injunctions 77
99 Undertakings as to costs 77
100 Powers of court if requirement of Monitor or inspector not
complied with 77
101 Non-punitive orders—Corrective advertising orders 78
102 Punitive orders—Adverse publicity orders 79
103 Defences 80
104 Findings in proceedings to be evidence 81
105 Orders against persons found to have contravened this Act 82
106 Public warning statements 83
107 Complaints and evidence are privileged 84
-- 4 of 96 --
Section Page
v
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
PART 9—GENERAL 85
108 When is a person not liable? 85
109 Power to make request to the Essential Services Commission 85
110 Report 86
111 Regulations 87
112 Amendment of the Australian Consumer Law and Fair
Trading Act 2012 88
113 Amendment of the Essential Services Commission Act 2001 88
114 Amendment of the Fire Services Property Levy Act 2012 89
115 Amendment of Public Administration Act 2004 89
116 Transitional provisions 89
Division 6—Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012 89
137A Director to succeed Fire Services Levy Monitor 89
117 Sunset 90
═══════════════
ENDNOTES 91
-- 5 of 96 --
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
Authorised Version
1
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012†
No. 81 of 2012
[Assented to 18 December 2012]
The Parliament of Victoria enacts:
PART 1—PRELIMINARY
1 Purpose
The purpose of this Act is to provide for the
establishment, functions and powers of the Fire
Services Levy Monitor.
2 Commencement
(1) This Act, other than sections 113(2) and 115(2),
comes into operation on the day after the day on
which this Act receives the Royal Assent.
Victoria
-- 6 of 96 --
Part 1—Preliminary
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
2
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(2) Sections 113(2) and 115(2) come into operation
on 30 December 2014.
3 Definitions
In this Act—
Director has the same meaning as it has in
section 3(1) of the Australian Consumer
Law and Fair Trading Act 2012;
Essential Services Commission means the
Essential Services Commission established
under the Essential Services Commission
Act 2001;
fire services levy means an amount included in the
premium payable for a policy of insurance
against fire for the purpose of recouping
contributions required to be paid by an
insurance company under section 37(1)(c) of
the Metropolitan Fire Brigades Act 1958
or section 76(1)(b) of the Country Fire
Authority Act 1958, whether or not the
amount is disclosed as a separate item;
fire services levy dispute means any dispute
between an insurance company and the
holder of a policy for insurance against fire
involving a claim that the insurance
company has engaged in—
(a) price exploitation as a result of the
abolition of the fire services levy; or
(b) prohibited conduct in relation to the
effect of the abolition of the fire
services levy;
fire services levy reform means the abolition of
the fire services levy by the Fire Services
Property Levy Act 2012;
s. 3
-- 7 of 96 --
Part 1—Preliminary
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
3
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
fire services property levy means the levy amount
calculated in accordance with Part 2 of the
Fire Services Property Levy Act 2012;
insurance against fire means insurance against
the risk of fire or the risk of loss of profits
consequent on fire whether the insurance is
associated with insurance against any other
risk or not;
insurance company means—
(a) a person (including a body corporate or
unincorporate, a partnership or an
underwriter) who, in Victoria, issues, or
undertakes liability under, policies of
insurance against fire in respect of
property in Victoria; or
(b) a Lloyd's underwriter who—
(i) issues, or undertakes liability
under, policies of insurance
against fire in respect of property
in Victoria; and
(ii) is a member of the Australian Fire
Brigades Charges Scheme and
makes payments to the Fund
established under that Scheme;
insurance premium means any premium received
by or due to an insurance company for
insurance against fire including any base
premium, fire services levy, GST or stamp
duty;
Lloyd's means the society of that name
incorporated by the Act of the United
Kingdom known as Lloyd's Act 1871;
s. 3
-- 8 of 96 --
Part 1—Preliminary
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
4
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
Lloyd's underwriter means an underwriter
member of Lloyd's;
Monitor means the Fire Services Levy Monitor
appointed under section 8 and includes the
Deputy Fire Services Levy Monitor while
acting as the Fire Services Levy Monitor;
non-party consumer means a person who is not,
or has not been, a party to a proceeding—
(a) in relation to a contravention of a
penalty provision; or
(b) instituted under Part 8, other than
section 80 or 81;
pecuniary penalty order means an order under
section 32 for the payment of a pecuniary
penalty;
penalty provision means section 26 or 31;
prescribed means prescribed by regulations made
under this Act;
price in relation to the supply of a regulated
contract of insurance includes—
(a) a charge of any description for the
supply; and
(b) any pecuniary or other benefit, whether
direct or indirect, received or to be
received by a person for or in
connection with the supply;
price exploitation has the meaning given by
section 26;
prohibited conduct means the conduct prohibited
by section 31;
s. 3
-- 9 of 96 --
Part 1—Preliminary
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
5
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
regulated contract of insurance means—
(a) a policy of insurance against fire; or
(b) a combined or comprehensive policy of
insurance which includes insurance
against fire—
issued by an insurance company whether
before, on or after the commencement of this
Act;
substantiation notice means a notice given under
section 76;
trade or commerce has the same meaning as it has
in the Australian Consumer Law (Victoria);
Victorian Consumer Law Fund means the
trust account required to be kept under
section 134(1) of the Australian Consumer
Law and Fair Trading Act 2012.
__________________
s. 3
-- 10 of 96 --
Part 2—The Fire Services Levy Monitor
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
6
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
PART 2—THE FIRE SERVICES LEVY MONITOR
4 Establishment of office of the Fire Services Levy
Monitor
(1) There is to be an office of the Fire Services Levy
Monitor.
(2) The Monitor is the public service body Head of
the office of the Fire Services Levy Monitor for
the purposes of section 16 of the Public
Administration Act 2004.
5 Independence of the Monitor
(1) Subject to this Act and other laws of the State, the
Monitor has complete discretion in the
performance or exercise of his or her functions
and powers.
(2) In particular, and without limiting subsection (1),
but subject to subsection (3), the Monitor is not
subject to the direction or control of the Minister
in respect of the performance or exercise by the
Monitor of his or her functions and powers in
respect of a specific matter or complaint.
(3) The Minister may issue a general direction in
writing to the Monitor in respect of the
performance by the Monitor of his or her
functions under this Act.
(4) A general direction issued under subsection (3)
must as soon as practicable after it is given to the
Monitor be published in the Government Gazette.
(5) The Monitor must comply with a general direction
given under subsection (3).
s. 4
-- 11 of 96 --
Part 2—The Fire Services Levy Monitor
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
7
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
6 Functions of the Monitor
(1) The functions of the Monitor are to—
(a) provide information, advice and guidance in
relation to fire services levy reform;
(b) monitor insurance premiums for insurance
against fire received by, or owing to, an
insurance company, including any base
premium, fire services levy, GST or stamp
duty;
(c) monitor the compliance of the insurance
industry with the prohibition on price
exploitation, and investigate and take
enforcement action;
(d) monitor compliance with the prohibition on
false, misleading or deceptive conduct in
respect of the effect or likely effect of fire
services levy reform;
(e) refer complaints to the—
(i) Australian Securities and Investments
Commission;
(ii) Australian Prudential Regulatory
Authority;
(iii) Financial Ombudsman Service;
(f) promote effective dispute resolution
mechanisms in relation to disputes arising
out of fire services levy reform;
(g) be responsible for the administration of this
Act;
(h) perform any other functions conferred on the
Monitor by or under this Act or any other
Act.
s. 6
-- 12 of 96 --
Part 2—The Fire Services Levy Monitor
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
8
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(2) Without limiting the generality of subsection (1),
the Monitor has the following functions—
(a) to advise persons of their rights and
obligations under this Act and the Fire
Services Property Levy Act 2012;
(b) to receive complaints from persons and to
deal with them in accordance with this Act,
including referring any complaint to any
other appropriate person;
(c) to monitor compliance with this Act and the
Fire Services Property Levy Act 2012;
(d) to prepare and publish guidelines in relation
to the operation and enforcement of this Act;
(e) to investigate breaches of this Act;
(f) to prosecute breaches of this Act;
(g) to institute and defend proceedings and take
any other action that may be necessary to
achieve compliance with the requirements of
this Act;
(h) to encourage the preparation and use of
codes of practice for guidance in
safeguarding and promoting the interests of
purchasers of regulated contracts of
insurance;
(i) to endorse a code of practice prepared by an
insurance company or a class of insurance
companies in respect of the supply of
regulated contracts of insurance to
purchasers of insurance or a class of
purchasers of insurance;
(j) to prepare codes of practice safeguarding and
promoting the interests of purchasers of
regulated contracts of insurance and submit
those codes of practice to the Minister for
inclusion in regulations made under this Act;
s. 6
-- 13 of 96 --
Part 2—The Fire Services Levy Monitor
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
9
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(k) in respect of matters arising out of the
administration of this Act or the Fire
Services Property Levy Act 2012—
(i) to investigate those matters; and
(ii) to conduct research; and
(iii) to collect and collate information;
(l) to report to the Minister on any matter in
relation to the administration of this Act or
the Fire Services Property Levy Act 2012
which the Monitor has investigated, either on
his or her own motion or at the request of the
Minister.
7 Powers of the Monitor
(1) The Monitor has all the powers necessary to
perform his or her functions.
(2) Without limiting subsection (1), the Monitor may
seek advice and information on any matter from
any person or body or source in performing the
functions of the Monitor.
8 Appointment of Fire Services Levy Monitor
(1) The Minister may appoint a person as the Fire
Services Levy Monitor.
(2) The Monitor is entitled to be paid the
remuneration and allowances that are determined
by the Minister.
(3) The Monitor holds office—
(a) for a period specified in his or her instrument
of appointment that ends on 31 December
2014;
(b) on the terms and conditions determined by
the Minister.
s. 7
-- 14 of 96 --
Part 2—The Fire Services Levy Monitor
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
10
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(4) The Fire Services Levy Monitor is, in respect of
that office, not subject to the Public
Administration Act 2004.
9 Appointment of Deputy Fire Services Monitor
(1) The Minister may appoint a person as the Deputy
Fire Services Levy Monitor.
(2) The Deputy Fire Services Levy Monitor is entitled
to be paid the remuneration and allowances that
are determined by the Minister.
(3) The Deputy Fire Services Levy Monitor holds
office—
(a) for a period specified in his or her instrument
of appointment that ends on 31 December
2014;
(b) on the terms and conditions determined by
the Minister.
(4) The Deputy Fire Services Levy Monitor is, in
respect of that office, not subject to the Public
Administration Act 2004.
(5) The Deputy Fire Services Levy Monitor has the
functions and powers which are delegated to him
or her under section 13 by the Fire Services Levy
Monitor.
(6) The Deputy Fire Services Levy Monitor is to act
as the Fire Services Levy Monitor if—
(a) the office of the Fire Services Levy Monitor
is vacant; or
(b) the Fire Services Levy Monitor is absent; or
(c) the Fire Services Levy Monitor is for any
other reason unable to perform the duties of
the office.
s. 9
-- 15 of 96 --
Part 2—The Fire Services Levy Monitor
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
11
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(7) While acting as the Fire Services Levy Monitor,
the Deputy Fire Services Levy Monitor has, and
may exercise all the powers, and must perform all
the functions of the Fire Services Levy Monitor.
10 Cessation of office
The Fire Services Levy Monitor or the Deputy
Fire Services Levy Monitor ceases to hold office
if he or she—
(a) resigns by notice in writing given to the
Minister; or
(b) becomes an insolvent under administration;
or
(c) becomes a represented person within the
meaning of the Guardianship and
Administration Act 1986; or
(d) is convicted of an indictable offence or an
offence that, if committed in Victoria, would
be an indictable offence; or
(e) nominates for election for the Parliament of
Victoria or of the Commonwealth or of
another State or a Territory of the
Commonwealth; or
(f) is removed from office under section 11.
11 Removal from office
(1) The Minister may remove the Fire Services Levy
Monitor or the Deputy Fire Services Levy
Monitor from office on any of the following
grounds—
(a) misconduct;
(b) neglect of duty;
(c) inability to perform the duties of the office;
s. 10
-- 16 of 96 --
Part 2—The Fire Services Levy Monitor
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
12
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(d) any other ground on which the Minister is
satisfied that the Fire Services Levy Monitor
or the Deputy Fire Services Levy Monitor is
unfit to hold office.
(2) The Minister must cause to be laid before each
House of Parliament a full statement of the
grounds of removal of the Fire Services Levy
Monitor or the Deputy Fire Services Levy
Monitor within 7 sitting days of that House after
the removal.
12 Effect of vacancy in office of the Monitor
A vacancy in the office of the Monitor does not
affect the validity or continuity of any act,
decision or proceeding made or commenced by
the Monitor.
13 Power of delegation
(1) The Monitor by instrument may delegate any
function or power of the Monitor under this Act
other than this power of delegation to—
(a) the Deputy Fire Services Levy Monitor;
(b) any person employed under Part 3 of the
Public Administration Act 2004.
(2) The Monitor by instrument may delegate to the
Director any function or power of the Monitor
under this Act including, subject to subsection (3),
this power of delegation.
(3) The Director may, subject to and in accordance
with the instrument of delegation under subsection
(2), by instrument delegate to any person
employed under Part 3 of the Public
Administration Act 2004 any function or power
delegated to the Director, other than this power of
delegation.
s. 12
-- 17 of 96 --
Part 2—The Fire Services Levy Monitor
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
13
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(4) Sections 42 and 42A of the Interpretation of
Legislation Act 1984 apply to a sub-delegation
under subsection (3) as if it were a delegation.
14 Staff
(1) Any employees that are necessary for the purposes
of this Act may be employed under Part 3 of the
Public Administration Act 2004.
(2) The Monitor may enter into agreements or
arrangements for the use of the services of any
staff of a Department, statutory authority or other
public body.
15 Consultants
(1) The Monitor may engage persons with suitable
qualifications and experience as consultants.
(2) Without limiting the generality of subsection (1),
the Monitor may appoint an Australian legal
practitioner to assist the Monitor as counsel, either
generally or in reference to a particular matter.
(3) An engagement under this section may be on any
terms and conditions the Monitor considers
appropriate.
16 Immunity
(1) A person who is the Fire Services Levy Monitor
or the Deputy Fire Services Levy Monitor is not
personally liable for anything done or omitted to
be done in good faith—
(a) in the performance of a function or the
exercise of a power under this Act; or
(b) in the reasonable belief that the act or
omission was in the performance of a
function or the exercise of a power under this
Act.
s. 14
-- 18 of 96 --
Part 2—The Fire Services Levy Monitor
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
14
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(2) Any liability resulting from an act or omission
that would but for subsection (1) attach to a
person who is the Fire Services Levy Monitor or
the Deputy Fire Services Levy Monitor attaches
instead to the Crown.
17 Secrecy
(1) This section applies to every person who is or has
been—
(a) the Fire Services Levy Monitor; or
(b) the Deputy Fire Services Levy Monitor; or
(c) the Director; or
(d) a person employed under section 14; or
(e) a person engaged under section 15; or
(f) any other person to whom a function or
power has been delegated under section 13.
(2) A person to whom this section applies must not,
either directly or indirectly, make a record of, or
disclose or communicate to any person, any
information concerning the affairs of any person
acquired by reason of—
(a) the office, employment or engagement
under, or for the purposes of, this Act; or
(b) performing any function or exercising any
power delegated to the person under this Act.
Penalty: 5 penalty units.
(3) Despite subsection (2), a person to whom this
section applies may—
(a) make a record of, or disclose or
communicate any information referred to in
that subsection—
(i) in any legal proceedings under this Act;
or
s. 17
-- 19 of 96 --
Part 2—The Fire Services Levy Monitor
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
15
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(ii) in the performance of a function or the
exercise of a power under or in
connection with this Act;
(b) divulge or communicate any information
referred to in that subsection to—
(i) the Minister; or
(ii) the Director; or
(iii) the Essential Services Commission; or
(iv) the Commissioner of State Revenue
under the Taxation Administration
Act 1997; or
(v) a court; or
(vi) the Australian Securities and
Investments Commission; or
(vii) the Australian Prudential Regulatory
Authority; or
(viii) the Financial Ombudsman Service; or
(ix) a prescribed person who is, or a
prescribed body which is, performing a
duty under or in connection with any
Act; or
(x) with the consent of the person to whom
the information relates, any other
person.
__________________
s. 17
-- 20 of 96 --
Part 3—Monitoring Powers
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
16
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
PART 3—MONITORING POWERS
18 Power to obtain information and documents to
monitor compliance
(1) The Monitor may, by notice in writing, require a
person who the Monitor believes is capable of
providing information or producing documents
that may assist the Monitor in monitoring
compliance with this Act and the Fire Services
Property Levy Act 2012—
(a) to provide to the Monitor, by writing signed
by that person or, in the case of a body
corporate, by a competent officer of the body
corporate, within the time and in the manner
specified in the notice, that information; or
(b) to produce to the Monitor, or to a person
specified in the notice acting on the
Monitor's behalf, in accordance with the
notice, those documents; or
(c) to appear before the Monitor at a time and
place specified in the notice to give that
information, either orally or in writing, and
produce those documents.
(2) A person must not—
(a) refuse or fail to comply with a notice under
this section to the extent that the person is
capable of complying with it; or
(b) in purported compliance with a notice under
this section, knowingly provide information
or give evidence that is false or misleading;
or
s. 18
-- 21 of 96 --
Part 3—Monitoring Powers
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
17
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(c) obstruct or hinder the Monitor in exercising a
power under this section.
Penalty: 20 penalty units, in the case of a natural
person;
100 penalty units, in the case of a body
corporate.
(3) Subject to subsection (4), a natural person is not
excused from answering a question, providing
information or producing or permitting the
inspection of a document on the ground that the
answer, information or document may tend to
incriminate the natural person.
(4) Despite subsection (3), the answer by a person to
any question asked in a notice under this section
or the provision by a person of any information or
the production by any person of a document in
compliance with a notice under this section is not
admissible in evidence against the person in any
proceedings other than proceedings under this
section.
(5) If any documents are produced to the Monitor
under this section, the Monitor may make copies
of or take extracts from the documents and retain
possession of those copies and extracts.
(6) Section 20 does not apply to documents produced
under this section.
19 Power to obtain information, documents and
evidence
(1) If the Monitor believes that a person is capable of
providing information, producing documents or
giving evidence relating to a matter that
constitutes, or may constitute, a contravention of
this Act, the Monitor may, by notice in writing,
require that person—
s. 19
-- 22 of 96 --
Part 3—Monitoring Powers
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
18
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(a) to provide to the Monitor, by writing signed
by that person or, in the case of a body
corporate, by a competent officer of the body
corporate, within the time and in the manner
specified in the notice, that information; or
(b) to produce to the Monitor, or to a person
specified in the notice acting on the
Monitor's behalf, in accordance with the
notice, those documents; or
(c) to appear before the Monitor, or a person
specified in the notice acting on the
Monitor's behalf, at a time and place
specified in the notice to give that evidence,
either orally or in writing, and produce those
documents.
(2) The Monitor or the person specified in the notice
acting on the Monitor's behalf may require the
evidence referred to in subsection (1)(c) to be
given on oath or affirmation and for that purpose
may administer an oath or affirmation.
(3) A person must not—
(a) refuse or fail to comply with a notice under
this section to the extent that the person is
capable of complying with it; or
(b) in purported compliance with a notice under
this section, knowingly provide information
or give evidence that is false or misleading;
or
(c) obstruct or hinder the Monitor in exercising a
power under this section.
Penalty: 60 penalty units, in the case of a natural
person;
300 penalty units, in the case of a body
corporate.
s. 19
-- 23 of 96 --
Part 3—Monitoring Powers
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
19
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(4) Subject to subsection (5), a natural person is not
excused from answering a question, providing
information or producing or permitting the
inspection of a document on the ground that the
answer, information or document may tend to
incriminate the natural person.
(5) Despite subsection (4), the answer by a person to
any question asked in a notice under this section
or the provision by a person of any information in
compliance with a notice under this section is not
admissible in evidence against the person—
(a) in the case of a person not being a body
corporate, in any criminal proceedings other
than proceedings under this section; or
(b) in the case of a body corporate, in any
criminal proceedings other than proceedings
under this Act.
20 Powers in relation to documents
If any documents are produced to the Monitor
under this Part, the Monitor may—
(a) inspect the documents or authorise a person
to inspect the documents;
(b) make copies of or take extracts of the
documents;
(c) seize the documents if the Monitor—
(i) considers the documents necessary for
obtaining evidence for the purpose of
any proceedings against any person
under this Act; or
(ii) believes on reasonable grounds that it is
necessary to seize the documents to
prevent their concealment, loss or
destruction or their use in the
contravention of this Act;
s. 20
-- 24 of 96 --
Part 3—Monitoring Powers
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
20
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(d) secure any seized documents against
interference;
(e) retain possession of the documents in
accordance with this Part.
21 Copies of seized documents
(1) If the Monitor retains possession of a document
seized from a person under this Part, the Monitor
must give the person, within 21 days of the
seizure, a copy of the document certified as
correct by the Monitor.
(2) A copy of a document certified under subsection
(1) is to be received in all courts and tribunals as
evidence of equal validity to the original.
22 Retention and return of seized documents
(1) If the Monitor seizes a document under this Part,
the Monitor must take reasonable steps to return
the document to the person from whom it was
seized if the reason for its seizure no longer exists.
(2) If the document seized has not been returned
within 3 months after it was seized, the Monitor
must take reasonable steps to return it unless—
(a) proceedings for the purpose for which the
document was retained have commenced
within that 3 month period and those
proceedings (including any appeal) have not
been completed; or
(b) the Magistrates' Court makes an order under
section 23 extending the period during which
the document may be retained.
23 Magistrates' Court may extend 3 month period
(1) The Monitor may apply to the Magistrates'
Court—
(a) within 3 months after seizing a document
under this Part; or
s. 21
-- 25 of 96 --
Part 3—Monitoring Powers
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
21
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(b) if an extension has been granted under this
section, before the end of the period of the
extension—
for an extension (not exceeding 3 months) of the
period for which the Monitor may retain the
document but so that the total period of retention
does not exceed 12 months.
(2) The Magistrates' Court may order such an
extension if it is satisfied that—
(a) it is in the interests of justice; and
(b) the total period of retention does not exceed
12 months; and
(c) retention of the document is necessary—
(i) for the purposes of an investigation into
whether a contravention of this Act has
occurred; or
(ii) to enable evidence of a contravention of
this Act to be obtained for the purposes
of a proceeding under this Act.
(3) The Magistrates' Court must consider the interests
of the owner of the document and may adjourn an
application to enable notice of the application to
be given to any person.
24 Service of documents
(1) A written requirement by the Monitor under this
Part may be given personally or by registered post
to a person—
(a) at the last known place of business,
employment or residence of the person; or
(b) in the case of a body corporate, at the
registered office of the body corporate.
s. 24
-- 26 of 96 --
Part 3—Monitoring Powers
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
22
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(2) A person who provides a document or information
in response to a requirement of the Monitor under
this Part may send that document or information
to the Monitor by registered post.
25 Information sharing
(1) The Monitor may enter into, or approve of, an
arrangement (an information sharing
arrangement) with a relevant agency for the
purposes of sharing or exchanging information
held by the Monitor and the relevant agency.
(2) The information to which an information sharing
arrangement may relate is limited to information
necessary for, or reasonably appropriate to, the
performance of the functions of the Monitor.
(3) Under an information sharing arrangement, the
Monitor and the relevant agency are authorised—
(a) to request and receive information held by
the other party to the arrangement; and
(b) to disclose information to the other party—
but only to the extent that the information is
reasonably necessary to assist in the exercise of
functions under this Act or the functions of the
relevant agency concerned.
(4) This section does not limit—
(a) the powers of the Monitor under this Part; or
(b) the operation of any other Act under which a
relevant agency is authorised or required to
disclose information to another person or
body; or
(c) the giving of information—
(i) to a court or tribunal in the course of
legal proceedings; or
s. 25
-- 27 of 96 --
Part 3—Monitoring Powers
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
23
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(ii) pursuant to an order of a court or
tribunal; or
(iii) to the extent reasonably required to
enable the investigation or the
enforcement of a law of the State or of
any other State or Territory or of the
Commonwealth; or
(iv) to the Director; or
(v) with the written authority of the
Secretary to the Department of Justice;
or
(vi) with the written authority of the person
to whom the information relates.
(5) In this section—
fair trading agency means an agency of the State,
or of the Commonwealth, or of another State
or Territory or of an overseas jurisdiction,
that exercises functions under an enactment
with respect to fair trading;
law enforcement agency means—
(a) the police force of Victoria or the
police force of another State or
Territory or of an overseas jurisdiction;
or
(b) the Australian Federal Police; or
(c) the Australian Crime Commission; or
(d) any other authority or person
responsible for the investigation or
prosecution of offences against the laws
of the State or of the Commonwealth,
another State or Territory or an
overseas jurisdiction;
s. 25
-- 28 of 96 --
Part 3—Monitoring Powers
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
24
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
relevant agency means—
(a) a fair trading agency; or
(b) a law enforcement agency; or
(c) the Essential Services Commission; or
(d) the State Revenue Office; or
(e) the Secretary to the Department of
Treasury and Finance; or
(f) any other agency of the State or of the
Commonwealth, another State or
Territory or an overseas jurisdiction; or
(g) any other person or body that exercises
functions, in the public interest, that
involve protecting the interests of
consumers.
__________________
s. 25
-- 29 of 96 --
Part 4—Price Exploitation and False, Misleading and Deceptive Practices
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
25
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
PART 4—PRICE EXPLOITATION AND FALSE,
MISLEADING AND DECEPTIVE PRACTICES
Division 1—Price exploitation
26 Price exploitation in relation to the fire services levy
reform
(1) An insurance company contravenes this section if
it engages in price exploitation in relation to the
fire services levy reform.
(2) For the purposes of this section, an insurance
company engages in price exploitation in relation
to the fire services levy reform if—
(a) the insurance company issues a regulated
contract of insurance; and
(b) the price for the supply of the regulated
contract of insurance is unreasonably high
having regard to—
(i) the fire services levy reform;
(ii) the amount to be contributed under
section 37 of the Metropolitan Fire
Brigades Act 1958 by insurance
companies insuring against fire
property situated within the
metropolitan district;
(iii) the amount to be contributed under
section 76 of the Country Fire
Authority Act 1958 by insurance
companies insuring against fire
property situated within the country
area of Victoria;
(iv) the historical fire services levy rates
charged by the insurance company;
s. 26
-- 30 of 96 --
Part 4—Price Exploitation and False, Misleading and Deceptive Practices
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
26
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(v) the costs of supplying insurance against
fire;
(vi) any other prescribed matters.
27 Price exploitation guidelines
(1) The Monitor may issue guidelines about when
prices for regulated contracts of insurance may be
regarded as being in contravention of section 26.
(2) The Monitor may at any time vary guidelines
issued under subsection (1).
(3) Guidelines issued under subsection (1) and any
variation made under subsection (2) must be
published—
(a) in the Government Gazette; and
(b) on an Internet site maintained by the
Department of Justice.
(4) The Monitor must have regard to the guidelines
when making any decision under section 28 or 29.
(5) A court may have regard to the guidelines in any
proceedings relating to a contravention of
section 26.
28 Monitor may issue notice to insurance company for
a contravention of section 26
(1) If the Monitor considers that an insurance
company has contravened section 26, the Monitor
may give the insurance company a notice in
writing under this section.
(2) The notice must—
(a) state that it has been given under this section;
(b) specify the name of the insurance company
that supplied the regulated contract of
insurance and details of the regulated
contract of insurance;
s. 27
-- 31 of 96 --
Part 4—Price Exploitation and False, Misleading and Deceptive Practices
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
27
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(c) state that in the Monitor's opinion the price
of the supply was unreasonably high
having regard to the matters specified in
section 26(2)(b).
(3) The Monitor may vary or revoke a notice given
under this section on its own initiative or on the
application of the insurance company to which it
was given.
(4) The Monitor must give notice in writing to the
insurance company of any variation or revocation
under subsection (3).
(5) A notice given under this section is in any
proceedings for a contravention of section 26 to
be taken to be evidence that the price of the
supply was unreasonably high having regard to
the matters specified in section 26(2)(b) in the
absence of any evidence to the contrary.
29 Monitor may give notice to aid prevention of price
exploitation
(1) The Monitor may give an insurance company a
notice in writing under this section if the Monitor
considers that doing so will aid the prevention of
price exploitation.
(2) The notice must—
(a) state that it has been given under this section;
(b) specify the name of the insurance company
to which it applies;
(c) specify that it applies in respect of a
regulated contract of insurance supplied by
that insurance company;
(d) specify the maximum price that, in the
Monitor's opinion, may be charged for a
regulated contract of insurance to which the
notice relates.
s. 29
-- 32 of 96 --
Part 4—Price Exploitation and False, Misleading and Deceptive Practices
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
28
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(3) The Monitor may vary or revoke a notice given
under this section on its own initiative or on the
application of the insurance company to which it
was given.
(4) The Monitor must give notice in writing to the
insurance company of any variation or revocation
under subsection (3).
30 Monitor may monitor prices
(1) The Monitor may monitor prices for either or both
of the following purposes—
(a) to assess the general effect of the fire
services levy reform on prices charged by
insurance companies for regulated contracts
of insurance;
(b) to assist in the consideration of whether
section 31 has been, is being, or may be,
contravened.
(2) The Monitor may, by notice in writing served on a
person, require the person—
(a) to give the Monitor specified information in
writing signed by the person or, if the person
is a body corporate, signed by a competent
officer of the body corporate; or
(b) to produce specified documents—
being information, or documents containing
information, relating to prices or the setting of
prices that the Monitor considers will or may be
useful to the Monitor in monitoring prices under
this section.
(3) Without limiting subsection (2), information or
documents that may be required under subsection
(2) may relate to prices, or the setting of prices,
whether before or after the commencement of the
fire services levy reform.
s. 30
-- 33 of 96 --
Part 4—Price Exploitation and False, Misleading and Deceptive Practices
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
29
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(4) A person must not—
(a) refuse or fail to comply with a notice under
subsection (2) to the extent that the person is
capable of complying with it; or
(b) in purported compliance with a notice under
subsection (2), intentionally or recklessly
provide information or a document that is
false or misleading.
Penalty: 20 penalty units, in the case of a natural
person;
100 penalty units, in the case of a body
corporate.
Note
The powers conferred by this section are in addition to the powers
conferred by section 18.
Division 2—Prohibited conduct
31 Prohibition on conduct falsely representing or
misleading or deceiving
A person must not engage in any conduct in trade
or commerce which—
(a) falsely represents (whether expressly or
impliedly) the effect, or likely effect, of the
fire services levy reform; or
(b) misleads or deceives, or is likely to mislead
or deceive, any person about the effect or
likely effect, of the fire services levy reform.
Division 3—Pecuniary penalties
32 Pecuniary penalty for contravention of penalty
provision
(1) The Monitor may apply to the Supreme Court for
an order under this Part in respect of the
contravention by a person of a penalty provision
s. 31
-- 34 of 96 --
Part 4—Price Exploitation and False, Misleading and Deceptive Practices
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
30
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
or the doing by a person of any other thing
mentioned in subsection (2).
(2) If the Supreme Court is satisfied that a person
has—
(a) contravened a penalty provision; or
(b) attempted to contravene a penalty provision;
or
(c) aided, abetted, counselled or procured a
person to contravene a penalty provision; or
(d) induced, or attempted to induce, a person
whether by threats or promises or otherwise,
to contravene a penalty provision; or
(e) been in any way, directly or indirectly,
knowingly concerned in, or a party to, the
contravention by a person of a penalty
provision; or
(f) conspired with others to contravene a penalty
provision—
the Supreme Court may order the person to pay a
pecuniary penalty to the Minister in respect of
each act or omission by the person to which this
section applies as the Supreme Court determines
to be appropriate, being an amount not exceeding
$500 000 in the case of a natural person, or not
exceeding $10 000 000 in the case of a body
corporate.
(3) In determining the amount of the pecuniary
penalty to be paid by the person, the Supreme
Court may have regard to all the relevant matters
including—
(a) the nature and extent of the act or omission
and of any loss or damage suffered as a
result of the act or omission; and
s. 32
-- 35 of 96 --
Part 4—Price Exploitation and False, Misleading and Deceptive Practices
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
31
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(b) the circumstances in which the act or
omission took place; and
(c) whether the person has previously been
found by the Supreme Court to have
contravened a penalty provision.
(4) An application under subsection (1) must be made
before 31 December 2014.
33 Defence to proceedings under section 32 relating to
a contravention of section 31
(1) In proceedings against a person (the respondent)
under section 32 in relation to an alleged
contravention of section 31, it is a defence if the
respondent establishes that the contravention in
respect of which the proceedings were
instituted—
(a) was due to a reasonable mistake; or
(b) was due to reasonable reliance on
information supplied by another person; or
(c) was due to the act or default of another
person, to an accident or to some other cause
beyond the respondent's control and the
respondent took reasonable precautions and
exercised due diligence to avoid the
contravention.
(2) In subsection (1)(b) and (c), another person does
not include a person who was—
(a) a servant or agent of the respondent; or
(b) if the respondent is a body corporate, a
director, servant or agent of the respondent—
at the time when the alleged contravention
occurred.
s. 33
-- 36 of 96 --
Part 4—Price Exploitation and False, Misleading and Deceptive Practices
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
32
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(3) In this section, contravention of section 31
includes conduct referred to in section 32(2)(b),
(c), (d), (e) or (f) which relates to a contravention
of section 31.
34 What happens if substantially the same conduct is a
contravention of section 31 and is an offence?
(1) The Supreme Court must not make a pecuniary
penalty order against a person in relation to a
contravention of section 31 if the person has been
convicted of an offence constituted by conduct
which is substantially the same as the conduct
constituting the contravention.
(2) Proceedings for a pecuniary penalty order
against a person in relation to a contravention of
section 31 are stayed if—
(a) criminal proceedings are commenced or have
already been commenced against the person
for an offence; and
(b) the offence is constituted by conduct that is
substantially the same as the conduct alleged
to constitute the contravention of section 31.
(3) Proceedings for a pecuniary penalty order
against a person in relation to a contravention of
section 31 stayed under subsection (2)—
(a) may be re-commenced if the person is not
convicted of the offence;
(b) must be dismissed if the person is convicted
of the offence.
(4) Criminal proceedings may be commenced against
a person for conduct which is substantially the
same as conduct constituting a contravention of
section 31 regardless of whether a pecuniary
penalty order has been made against the person in
respect of the contravention of section 31.
s. 34
-- 37 of 96 --
Part 4—Price Exploitation and False, Misleading and Deceptive Practices
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
33
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(5) Subject to subsection (6), evidence of information
given, or evidence of production of documents, by
a natural person is not admissible in criminal
proceedings against the natural person if—
(a) the natural person previously gave the
evidence or produced the document in
proceedings for a pecuniary penalty order
against the natural person for a contravention
of section 31, whether or not the pecuniary
penalty order was made; and
(b) the conduct alleged to constitute the offence
is substantially the same as the conduct that
was claimed to constitute the contravention
of section 31.
(6) Subsection (5) does not apply to a criminal
proceeding in respect of the falsity of the evidence
given by the natural person in the proceedings for
the pecuniary penalty order.
(7) In this section, contravention of section 31
includes conduct referred to in section 32(2)(b),
(c), (d), (e) or (f) which relates to a contravention
of section 31.
35 Conduct contravening more than one pecuniary
penalty provision
(1) Subject to subsection (2), if conduct constitutes a
contravention of more than one pecuniary penalty
provision, proceedings may be instituted under
this Division against a person in relation to the
contravention of any one of those provisions.
(2) A person is not liable to more than one pecuniary
penalty under this Division in relation to the same
conduct.
s. 35
-- 38 of 96 --
Part 4—Price Exploitation and False, Misleading and Deceptive Practices
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
34
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
36 Civil evidence and procedure rules for pecuniary
penalty order
The Supreme Court must apply the rules of
evidence and procedure for civil matters when
hearing an application for a pecuniary penalty
order.
37 Evidence given in civil proceedings not admissible in
criminal proceedings
(1) Subject to subsection (2), evidence of information
given, or evidence of documents, by a person is
not admissible in criminal proceedings against the
person if—
(a) the person previously gave the information
or produced the document in proceedings for
a pecuniary penalty order against the person
for an alleged contravention of a pecuniary
penalty provision, whether or not the
pecuniary penalty order was made; and
(b) the conduct alleged to constitute the offence
is the same, or substantially the same, as the
conduct alleged to constitute a contravention
of the pecuniary penalty provision.
(2) Subsection (1) does not apply to criminal
proceedings in relation to the falsity of evidence
given by the person in the proceedings for the
pecuniary penalty provision.
38 State of mind
(1) In proceedings for a pecuniary penalty order
against a person for a contravention of a pecuniary
penalty provision, it is not necessary to prove—
(a) the person's intention; or
(b) the person's knowledge; or
(c) any other state of mind of the person.
s. 36
-- 39 of 96 --
Part 4—Price Exploitation and False, Misleading and Deceptive Practices
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
35
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(2) Subsection (1) does not apply to the extent that the
proceedings relate to a contravention of section 31
being conduct referred to in section 32(2)(b), (c),
(d), (e) or (f).
(3) Subsection (1) does not affect the operation of
section 33.
39 Pecuniary penalty to be paid into Consolidated
Fund
The Minister must pay any pecuniary penalty
received by the Minister into the Consolidated
Fund.
__________________
s. 39
-- 40 of 96 --
Part 5—Codes of Practice
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
36
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
PART 5—CODES OF PRACTICE
40 Preparation of draft code of practice by the Monitor
(1) The Monitor may, with the approval of the
Minister, prepare for submission to the Minister a
draft code of practice in relation to the supply of
regulated contracts—
(a) by a particular insurance company; or
(b) by a particular class of insurance companies
and a particular class of purchasers of
insurance.
(2) The Monitor must prepare and submit a draft code
of practice under subsection (1) if directed by the
Minister.
41 Consideration of draft code of practice
If the Monitor is satisfied that a particular
insurance company or a particular class of
insurance companies have, in consultation with
other interested persons, agreed to abide by a
particular code of practice in the supply of
insurance, the Monitor may submit the code to the
Minister for consideration together with any
recommendations of the Monitor with respect to
the code.
42 Prescribing codes of practice
The Minister may—
(a) recommend to the Governor in Council that
the Governor in Council make regulations
prescribing a code of practice which—
(i) has been prepared and submitted to the
Minister under section 40; or
(ii) has been submitted to the Minister
under section 41; or
s. 40
-- 41 of 96 --
Part 5—Codes of Practice
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
37
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(b) recommend that the Governor in Council
make regulations prescribing such a code of
practice with the amendments made by the
Minister.
43 Offence to breach code of practice
A person must comply with a code of practice
prescribed under this Act.
Penalty: 300 penalty units.
__________________
s. 43
-- 42 of 96 --
Part 6—Fire Service Levy Disputes
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
38
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
PART 6—FIRE SERVICE LEVY DISPUTES
44 Making a fire services levy dispute complaint
(1) Any person may make a fire services levy dispute
complaint to the Monitor.
(2) A person may complain to the Monitor in writing.
(3) The Monitor may ask a person who has made a
complaint to give more information about the
complaint within the time fixed by the Monitor.
(4) A person who has made a complaint must give his
or her name to the Monitor and such other
information relating to his or her identity as the
Monitor may require.
45 Conciliation and mediation
(1) The Monitor may refer a fire services levy dispute
complaint to the Director for conciliation or
mediation.
(2) A fire services levy dispute complaint referred to
the Director under subsection (1) must be
reasonably likely to be settled.
(3) If the whole or any part of a fire services levy
dispute complaint under subsection (1) falls
within the jurisdiction of any prescribed person or
body, the Director must refer the complaint, or
that part of the complaint, to the person or body
within whose jurisdiction it falls.
(4) In this section, prescribed person or body
means—
(a) a body referred to in section 6(1)(e); and
(b) any other person or body prescribed for the
purposes of this section.
s. 44
-- 43 of 96 --
Part 6—Fire Service Levy Disputes
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
39
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
46 Powers of the Director in relation to certain
proceedings
(1) The Director may, subject to this section, institute
or continue proceedings on behalf of, or defend
proceedings brought against, a person or persons
in respect of a fire services levy dispute.
(2) The Director must not, under subsection (1),
institute or continue or defend proceedings unless
the Director is satisfied—
(a) that the person or persons have a good cause
of action or a good defence to an action
relating to the fire services levy dispute; and
(b) that it is in the public interest to institute,
continue or defend proceedings on behalf of
the person or persons.
(3) The Director must not, under subsection (1),
institute, continue or defend proceedings on behalf
of a person or persons unless—
(a) the person has or the persons have given
consent in writing; or
(b) in the case of group proceedings or
representative proceedings, the
representative party has given consent.
(4) After consent has been given under subsection
(3)(a) or (b), the Director may institute or continue
a proceeding or defence on behalf of a person or
persons even if the person revokes, or any of the
persons revoke, the consent.
47 Proceedings and costs
(1) If the Director institutes, continues or defends
proceedings on behalf of a person under
section 46—
s. 46
-- 44 of 96 --
Part 6—Fire Service Levy Disputes
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
40
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(a) the Director may settle the proceedings
either with or without obtaining judgment in
the proceedings; and
(b) if a judgment is obtained in the proceedings
in favour of the person, the Director may
take such steps as are necessary to enforce
the judgment; and
(c) an amount (other than an amount in respect
of costs) recovered by the Director in respect
of the person in the proceedings is payable to
the person; and
(d) an amount in respect of costs recovered in
the proceedings is payable to the Director;
and
(e) the person is liable to pay an amount
(not being an amount of costs) awarded
against the person in the proceedings; and
(f) the Director is liable to pay the costs of or
incidental to the proceedings that are payable
by the person.
(2) If, in proceedings instituted, continued or
defended on behalf of a person under section 46—
(a) a party to the proceedings files a
counterclaim; or
(b) the person is entitled to file a counterclaim—
and the counterclaim is not or would not be
related to the proceedings and to the interests of
the person in the dispute, the Director may apply
to the court hearing the proceedings for an order
that the counterclaim not be heard in the course of
those proceedings.
s. 47
-- 45 of 96 --
Part 6—Fire Service Levy Disputes
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
41
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(3) If the court makes an order under subsection (2),
the court may make any ancillary or consequential
orders that it thinks just.
__________________
s. 47
-- 46 of 96 --
Part 7—Inspection Powers
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
42
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
PART 7—INSPECTION POWERS
Division 1—Inspectors
48 Appointment of inspectors
(1) The Monitor may appoint as an inspector—
(a) a person employed under Part 3 of the
Public Administration Act 2004;
(b) a person appointed as an inspector,
enforcement officer or authorised officer by
or under any other Act.
(2) An appointment under subsection (1) must be
made by instrument.
(3) The Monitor must not appoint a person as an
inspector unless the Monitor is satisfied that the
person is appropriately qualified or has
successfully completed appropriate training.
49 Inspector's identification
(1) The Monitor must issue identification to each
inspector.
(2) Identification must contain a photograph of the
inspector to whom it is issued.
50 Production of identification
(1) An inspector must produce his or her
identification for inspection—
(a) before exercising a power under this Part;
and
(b) at any time during the exercise of a power
under this Part, if asked to do so.
Penalty: 10 penalty units.
(2) Subsection (1) does not apply to a requirement
made by post.
s. 48
-- 47 of 96 --
Part 7—Inspection Powers
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
43
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
Division 2—Requirements to produce information
51 Inspector may seek court order
(1) If an inspector believes on reasonable grounds that
a person may have contravened this Act, the
inspector may apply to the Magistrates' Court for
an order requiring any person at a time and place
specified by the inspector—
(a) to answer orally or in writing any questions
put by an inspector in relation to the alleged
contravention;
(b) to supply orally or in writing information
required by an inspector in relation to the
alleged contravention;
(c) to produce to an inspector specified
documents or documents of a specified class
relating to the alleged contravention.
(2) An application under subsection (1) must be made
with the written approval of the Monitor.
(3) The Magistrates' Court may make the order if the
Magistrates' Court is satisfied that there are
reasonable grounds to believe that a person may
have contravened this Act.
(4) An order must state a day, not later than 28 days
after the making of the order, on which the order
ceases to have effect.
52 Inspection of documents under court order
(1) If any documents are produced to an inspector
under an order made under section 51, the
inspector may—
(a) inspect the documents or authorise a person
to inspect the documents;
(b) make copies of or take extracts of the
documents;
s. 51
-- 48 of 96 --
Part 7—Inspection Powers
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
44
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(c) seize the documents;
(d) secure any seized documents against
interference;
(e) retain possession of the documents in
accordance with this Part.
(2) An inspector may only seize documents under
subsection (1)(c) if the inspector considers the
documents necessary for the purpose of obtaining
evidence for the purpose of any proceedings
against any person under this Act.
53 Notification of execution of court order
(1) An inspector who executes an order under this
Division must, as soon as practicable after the
execution of the order, notify the Magistrates'
Court in writing of—
(a) the time and place of execution; and
(b) the documents or classes of documents
seized; and
(c) if documents were seized under
section 52(1)(c) in respect of an alleged
contravention other than a contravention for
which the order was made, the alleged
contravention in respect of which the
documents were seized.
(2) The Magistrates' Court may direct the inspector to
bring before the court a document to which
subsection (1)(c) applies so that the matter may be
dealt with according to law.
(3) The Magistrates' Court may direct that a document
brought before it under subsection (2) be returned
to its owner, if in the opinion of the Magistrates'
Court the document can be returned consistently
with the interests of justice.
s. 53
-- 49 of 96 --
Part 7—Inspection Powers
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
45
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(4) A direction under subsection (3) may be subject to
any condition the court thinks fit.
Division 3—Entry and search of premises with consent
54 Entry and search with consent
(1) If an inspector believes on reasonable grounds that
a person has contravened this Act, the inspector,
with the consent of the occupier of premises,
may—
(a) enter and search the premises; and
(b) exercise a power referred to in subsections
(2) and (3) at the premises.
(2) An inspector may—
(a) seize any thing the inspector finds on the
premises if the inspector believes on
reasonable grounds the thing is connected
with the alleged contravention;
(b) in the case of any document on the premises,
do any of the following in relation to the
document, if the inspector believes on
reasonable grounds the document is
connected with the alleged contravention—
(i) require the document to be produced
for examination;
(ii) examine, make copies or take extracts
from the document, or arrange for the
making of copies or the taking of
extracts;
(iii) remove the document for so long as is
reasonably necessary to make copies or
take extracts from the document.
s. 54
-- 50 of 96 --
Part 7—Inspection Powers
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
46
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(3) An inspector may make any still or moving image
or audio-visual recording if the inspector believes
on reasonable grounds it is necessary to do so for
the purpose of establishing the alleged
contravention.
55 Notice before entry and search
An inspector must not enter and search any
premises under section 54 unless, before the
occupier consents to the entry and search, the
inspector has—
(a) produced his or her identification for
inspection; and
(b) informed the occupier—
(i) of the purpose of the search; and
(ii) that the occupier may refuse to give
consent to the entry and search or to the
seizure of any thing found during the
search; and
(iii) that the occupier may refuse to give
consent to the taking of any copy or
extract from a document found on the
premises during the search; and
(iv) that any thing seized or taken during
the search with the consent of the
occupier may be used in evidence in
proceedings.
56 Acknowledgement of consent to entry and search
(1) If an occupier of premises consents to the entry
and search of the premises by an inspector under
section 54, the inspector must, before entering the
premises, ask the occupier to sign an
acknowledgment.
s. 55
-- 51 of 96 --
Part 7—Inspection Powers
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
47
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(2) For the purpose of subsection (1), the
acknowledgment must state—
(a) that the occupier has been informed—
(i) of the purpose of the search; and
(ii) that the occupier may refuse to give
consent to the entry and search or to the
seizure of any thing found during the
search; and
(iii) that the occupier may refuse to give
consent to the taking of any copy or
extract from a document found on the
premises during the search; and
(iv) that any thing seized or taken during
the search with the consent of the
occupier may be used in evidence in
proceedings; and
(b) that the occupier has consented to the entry
and search; and
(c) the date and time that the occupier
consented.
(3) If an occupier of premises consents to the seizure
or taking of any thing during a search of the
premises by the inspector, the inspector must,
before seizing or taking the thing, ask the occupier
to sign an acknowledgement.
(4) For the purpose of subsection (3), the
acknowledgment must state—
(a) that the occupier has consented to the seizure
or taking of the thing; and
(b) the date and time that the occupier
consented.
(5) An inspector must give a copy of a signed
acknowledgement to the occupier before leaving
the premises.
s. 56
-- 52 of 96 --
Part 7—Inspection Powers
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
48
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(6) If, in any proceeding, a signed acknowledgment is
not produced to the court or a tribunal, it must be
presumed, until the contrary is proved, that the
occupier did not consent to the entry and search or
to the seizure or the taking of the thing.
Division 4—Entry and search of premises with warrant
57 Search warrants
(1) An inspector may apply to a magistrate for the
issue of a search warrant in relation to particular
premises, if the inspector believes on reasonable
grounds that there is on the premises evidence that
a person may have contravened this Act.
(2) An application under subsection (1) must be made
with the written approval of the Monitor.
(3) If a magistrate is satisfied by the evidence, on oath
or by affidavit, that there are reasonable grounds
to believe that there is a thing, or thing of a
particular kind, connected with a contravention of
this Act or the regulations on the premises, the
magistrate may issue the search warrant in
accordance with the Magistrates' Court Act
1989.
58 Form and content of search warrants
(1) A search warrant issued under section 57(3) may
authorise the inspector named in the warrant to
enter premises specified in the warrant, if
necessary by force, and do any of the following—
(a) if the inspector believes on reasonable
grounds that a thing, or thing of a particular
kind, named or described in the warrant is
connected with the alleged contravention—
(i) search for the thing;
(ii) seize the thing;
(iii) secure the thing against interference;
s. 57
-- 53 of 96 --
Part 7—Inspection Powers
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
49
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(iv) examine, inspect and take and keep
samples of the thing;
(b) in the case of any document, or document of
a particular kind, named or described in the
warrant, if the inspector believes on
reasonable grounds that the document is
connected with the alleged contravention—
(i) require the document to be produced
for inspection;
(ii) examine, make copies or take extracts
from the document, or arrange for the
making of copies or the taking of
extracts;
(iii) remove the document for so long as is
reasonably necessary to make copies or
take extracts from the document;
(c) make any still or moving image or audio-
visual recording of any thing of a particular
kind named or described in the warrant, if
the inspector believes on reasonable grounds
that it is connected with the alleged
contravention.
(2) A search warrant issued under section 57(3) may
authorise, in addition to an inspector, any other
person named or otherwise identified in the
warrant to execute the warrant.
(3) A search warrant issued under section 57(3) must
state—
(a) the purpose for which the search is required
and the nature of the alleged contravention;
and
s. 58
-- 54 of 96 --
Part 7—Inspection Powers
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
50
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(b) any conditions to which the warrant is
subject; and
(c) whether entry is authorised to be made at any
time of the day or night or during specified
hours of the day or night; and
(d) a day, not later than 28 days after the issue of
the warrant, on which the warrant ceases to
have effect.
(4) Except as provided by this Act, the rules to be
observed with respect to search warrants under the
Magistrates' Court Act 1989 extend and apply to
warrants issued under section 57(3).
59 Announcement before entry
(1) On executing a search warrant issued under
section 57(3), the inspector named in the
warrant—
(a) must announce that he or she is authorised
by the warrant to enter the premises; and
(b) if the inspector has been unable to obtain
unforced entry, must give any person at the
premises an opportunity to allow entry to the
premises.
(2) An inspector is not required to comply with
subsection (1) if he or she believes on reasonable
grounds that immediate entry to the premises is
required to ensure—
(a) the safety of any person; or
(b) that the effective execution of the search
warrant is not frustrated.
60 Details of warrant to be given to occupier
(1) If the occupier is present at premises where a
search warrant is being executed, the inspector
must—
s. 59
-- 55 of 96 --
Part 7—Inspection Powers
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
51
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(a) identify himself or herself to the occupier;
and
(b) give to the occupier a copy of the warrant.
(2) If the occupier is not present at premises where a
search warrant is being executed, the inspector
must—
(a) identify himself or herself to a person at the
premises; and
(b) give to the person a copy of the warrant.
61 Seizure of things not mentioned in the warrant
A search warrant issued under section 57(3)
authorises an inspector named in the warrant, in
addition to the seizure of any thing of the kind
described in the warrant, to seize any thing which
is not of the kind described in the warrant if—
(a) the inspector believes on reasonable grounds
that the thing—
(i) is of a kind which could have been
included in a search warrant issued
under this Part; or
(ii) will afford evidence about the
contravention of this Act; and
(b) in the case of the seizure of a thing, the
inspector believes on reasonable grounds that
it is necessary to seize that thing in order to
prevent its concealment, loss or destruction
or its use in the contravention of this Act.
Division 5—Documents
62 Copies of seized documents
(1) If an inspector retains possession of a document
seized from a person under this Part, the inspector
must give the person, within 21 days after the
s. 61
-- 56 of 96 --
Part 7—Inspection Powers
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
52
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
seizure, a copy of the document certified as
correct by the inspector.
(2) A copy of a document certified under subsection
(1) is to be received in all courts and tribunals to
be evidence of equal validity to the original.
63 Retention and return of seized documents or things
(1) If an inspector seizes a document or other thing
under this Part, the inspector must take reasonable
steps to return the document or thing to the person
from whom it was seized if the reason for its
seizure no longer exists.
(2) If the document or thing seized has not been
returned within 3 months after it was seized, the
inspector must take reasonable steps to return it
unless—
(a) proceedings for the purpose for which the
document or thing was retained have
commenced within that 3 month period and
those proceedings (including any appeal)
have not been completed; or
(b) the Magistrates' Court makes an order under
section 64 extending the period during which
the document or thing may be retained.
64 Magistrates' Court may extend 3 month period
(1) If an inspector seizes a document or other thing
under this Part, the inspector may apply to the
Magistrates' Court for an order for an extension,
not exceeding 3 months, of the period for which
the inspector may retain the document or thing.
(2) An application under subsection (1) must be
made—
(a) within 3 months after seizing a document or
other thing under this Part; or
s. 63
-- 57 of 96 --
Part 7—Inspection Powers
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
53
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(b) if an extension has been granted under this
section, before the end of the period of the
extension.
(3) The Magistrates' Court may make the order if it is
satisfied that—
(a) it is in the interests of justice; and
(b) the total period of retention does not exceed
12 months; and
(c) retention of the document or other thing is
necessary—
(i) for the purposes of an investigation into
whether a contravention of this Act has
occurred; or
(ii) to enable evidence of a contravention of
this Act to be obtained for the purposes
of a proceeding under this Act.
(4) At least 7 days prior to the hearing of an
application under this section, notice of the
application must be sent to the owner of the
document or thing described in the application.
Division 6—Offences
65 Refusal or failure to comply with requirement
A person must not, without reasonable excuse,
refuse or fail to comply with a requirement of the
Monitor or an inspector under this Part.
Penalty: 60 penalty units, in the case of a natural
person;
300 penalty units, in the case of a body
corporate.
s. 65
-- 58 of 96 --
Part 7—Inspection Powers
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
54
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
66 Protection against self-incrimination
(1) It is a reasonable excuse for a natural person to
refuse or fail to give information or do any other
thing that the person is required to do by or under
this Part, if the giving of the information or the
doing of that other thing would tend to incriminate
the person.
(2) Despite subsection (1), it is not a reasonable
excuse for a natural person to refuse or fail to
produce a document that the person is required to
produce by or under this Part, if the production of
the document would tend to incriminate the
person.
67 Offence to give false or misleading information
(1) A person must not give information to an
inspector under this Part that the person believes
to be false or misleading in any material
particular.
Penalty: 60 penalty units, in the case of a natural
person;
300 penalty units, in the case of a body
corporate.
(2) A person must not produce a document to an
inspector under this Part that the person knows to
be false or misleading in a material particular
without indicating the respect in which it is false
or misleading and, if practicable, providing
correct information.
Penalty: 60 penalty units, in the case of a natural
person;
300 penalty units, in the case of a body
corporate.
s. 66
-- 59 of 96 --
Part 7—Inspection Powers
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
55
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
68 Offence to hinder or obstruct inspector
A person must not, without reasonable excuse,
hinder or obstruct an inspector who is exercising a
power under this Part.
Penalty: 60 penalty units, in the case of a natural
person;
300 penalty units, in the case of a body
corporate.
69 Offence to impersonate inspector
A person who is not an inspector must not, in any
way, hold himself or herself out to be an
inspector.
Penalty: 60 penalty units.
Division 7—Miscellaneous
70 Entry to be reported to the Monitor
(1) If an inspector exercises a power of entry under
this Part, the inspector must report the exercise of
the power to the Monitor within 7 days after the
entry.
(2) The report must include all relevant details of the
entry including—
(a) the time and place of the entry; and
(b) the purpose of the entry; and
(c) a description of things done while on the
premises, including details of things seized,
copies made and extracts taken; and
(d) the time of departure.
71 Requirement to assist inspector during entry
To the extent that it is reasonably necessary to
determine compliance with this Act, an inspector
exercising a power of entry under this Part who
produces his or her identification for inspection by
s. 68
-- 60 of 96 --
Part 7—Inspection Powers
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
56
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
the occupier of the premises or an agent or
employee of the occupier may require that
person—
(a) to give information to the inspector, orally or
in writing; and
(b) to produce documents to the inspector; and
(c) to give reasonable assistance to the inspector.
72 Register of exercise of powers of entry
The Monitor must keep a register containing the
particulars of all matters reported to the Monitor
under section 70.
73 Complaints
(1) Any person may complain to the Monitor about
the exercise of a power by an inspector under this
Part.
(2) The Monitor must—
(a) investigate any complaint made to the
Monitor; and
(b) provide a written report to the complainant
on the results of the investigation.
74 Service of documents
(1) A written requirement by an inspector under this
Part may be—
(a) given personally or sent by registered post to
a person at the last known place of business,
employment or residence of the person; or
(b) in the case of a body corporate, given
personally or sent by post at the registered
office of the body corporate.
s. 72
-- 61 of 96 --
Part 7—Inspection Powers
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
57
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(2) A person who provides a document or information
in response to a requirement of an inspector under
this Part may send that document or information
to the Monitor by registered post.
75 Confidentiality
(1) An inspector must not disclose to any other
person, whether directly or indirectly, any
information obtained by the inspector in carrying
out his or her functions under this Part.
Penalty: 60 penalty units.
(2) Subsection (1) does not apply to the disclosure of
information—
(a) to the extent necessary to carry out the
inspector's functions under this Part; or
(b) to a court or tribunal in the course of legal
proceedings; or
(c) pursuant to an order of a court or tribunal; or
(d) to the extent reasonably required to enable
the investigation or the enforcement of a law
of this State or of any other State or Territory
or of the Commonwealth; or
(e) to the Essential Services Commission; or
(f) with the written authority of the Monitor; or
(g) with the written authority of the person to
whom the information relates.
__________________
s. 75
-- 62 of 96 --
Part 8—Remedies and Legal Proceedings
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
58
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
PART 8—REMEDIES AND LEGAL PROCEEDINGS
Division 1—Substantiation notices
76 Monitor may require claim to be substantiated
(1) Subject to subsection (6), this section applies if a
person has made a claim or representation in trade
or commerce as to the effect or likely effect of the
fire services levy reform.
(2) The Monitor may give the person who made the
claim or representation a written notice requiring
the person to do any one or more of the
following—
(a) give information or produce documents or
both to the Monitor that could be capable of
substantiating or supporting the claim or
representation;
(b) if the claim or representation relates to the
supply, or possible supply, of a regulated
contract of insurance by the person or
another person, give information or produce
documents or both to the Monitor that could
be capable of substantiating or supporting
the claim or representation;
(c) give information or produce documents or
both to the Monitor that are of a kind
specified in the notice—
within 21 days after the notice is given to the
person who made the claim or representation.
(3) Any kind of information or documents that the
Monitor specifies under subsection (2)(c) must be
of a kind that the Monitor is satisfied is relevant
to—
s. 76
-- 63 of 96 --
Part 8—Remedies and Legal Proceedings
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
59
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(a) substantiating or supporting the claim or
representation; or
(b) if the claim or representation relates to the
supply, or possible supply, of a regulated
contract of insurance by the person or
another person, substantiating or supporting
the claim or representation.
(4) The substantiation notice must—
(a) state the name of the person to whom it is to
be given;
(b) specify the claim or representation to which
it relates;
(c) explain the effect of sections 77, 78 and 79.
(5) The substantiation notice may relate to more than
one claim or representation that the person has
made.
(6) This section does not apply to a person who
makes a claim or representation if the person—
(a) makes the claim or representation as an
information provider by publishing it on
behalf of another person in the course of
carrying on a business of providing
information; and
(b) does not have a commercial relationship with
the other person other than for the purpose
of—
(i) publishing claims or representations
promoting, or apparently intended to
promote, the other person's business or
other activities; or
(ii) the other person supplying insurance to
the person.
s. 76
-- 64 of 96 --
Part 8—Remedies and Legal Proceedings
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
60
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(7) In this section, information provider means a
person who carries on a business of providing
information.
(8) Without limiting the generality of subsection (7),
each of the following is an information provider—
(a) the holder of a licence granted under the
Broadcasting Services Act 1992 of the
Commonwealth;
(b) a person who is the provider of a
broadcasting service under a class licence
under that Act;
(c) the holder of a licence continued in force by
section 5(1) of the Broadcasting Services
(Transitional Provisions and Consequential
Amendments) Act 1992 of the
Commonwealth;
(d) the Australian Broadcasting Corporation;
(e) the Special Broadcasting Service
Corporation.
77 Extending period for complying with substantiation
notice
(1) A person who has been given a substantiation
notice may, at any time within the period of
21 days after the substantiation notice was given
to the person by the Monitor, apply in writing to
the Monitor for an extension of the period for
complying with the substantiation notice.
(2) The Monitor may, by written notice given to the
person, extend the period within which the person
must comply with the substantiation notice.
s. 77
-- 65 of 96 --
Part 8—Remedies and Legal Proceedings
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
61
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
78 Compliance with a substantiation notice
(1) A person who is given a substantiation notice
must comply with the substantiation notice within
the compliance period.
Penalty: 300 penalty units, in the case of a
natural person;
1500 penalty units, in the case of a
body corporate.
(2) In this section, compliance period means—
(a) the period of 21 days specified in the
compliance notice; or
(b) if the period for complying with the notice
has been extended under section 77, the
period as so extended—
and if an application has been made under
section 77(1) for an extension of the period
specified in the substantiation notice, includes the
period up until the time when the applicant is
given notice of the Monitor's decision on the
application.
(3) Despite subsection (1), a natural person may
refuse or fail to give particular information or
produce a particular document in compliance with
a substantiation notice on the ground that the
information or production of the document might
tend to incriminate the person or expose the
person to a penalty.
79 False or misleading information
(1) A person must not, in compliance or purported
compliance with a substantiation notice—
(a) give the Monitor false or misleading
information; or
s. 78
-- 66 of 96 --
Part 8—Remedies and Legal Proceedings
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
62
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(b) produce to the Monitor documents that
contain false or misleading information.
Penalty: 300 penalty units, in the case of a
natural person;
1500 penalty units, in the case of a
body corporate.
(2) This section does not apply to—
(a) information that the person could not have
known was false or misleading; or
(b) the production to the Monitor of a document
containing false or misleading information if
the document is accompanied by a statement
made by the person that the information is
false or misleading.
Division 2—Compensation orders
80 Compensation order on application of injured
person or the Monitor
(1) A court may on the application of—
(a) a person (the injured person) who has
suffered, or is likely to suffer, loss or
damage—
(i) because of the conduct of another
person that was engaged in a
contravention of this Act; or
(ii) as a consequence of the price for the
supply of a regulated contract of
insurance by an insurance company
being unreasonably high having
regard to the matters specified in
section 26(2)(b); or
s. 80
-- 67 of 96 --
Part 8—Remedies and Legal Proceedings
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
63
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(b) the Monitor made on behalf of one or more
injured persons—
make any order or orders under section 84 that the
court considers appropriate against the person
who engaged in the conduct, or a person involved
in the conduct, or where subparagraph (ii) applies,
the insurance company.
(2) The order must be an order that the court
considers will—
(a) compensate the injured person or injured
persons, in whole or in part for the loss or
damage; or
(b) prevent or reduce the loss or damage
suffered, or likely to be suffered, by the
injured person or injured persons.
(3) An application may be made under subsection (1)
even if proceedings in relation to the conduct in
contravention of this Act have not been instituted.
(4) The Monitor must not make an application under
subsection (1)(b) unless each person on whose
behalf the application is to be made has consented
in writing to the making of the application.
(5) An application under subsection (1) must be made
before 31 December 2014.
81 Order to redress loss or damage suffered by
non-party consumers
(1) If—
(a) a person is engaged in conduct in
contravention of this Act; and
(b) the conduct in contravention of this Act
caused, or is likely to cause, a class of
persons to suffer loss or damage; and
s. 81
-- 68 of 96 --
Part 8—Remedies and Legal Proceedings
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
64
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(c) the class of persons includes persons who are
non-party consumers in relation to the
conduct in contravention of this Act—
a court may, on the application of the Monitor,
make any order or orders (other than an award of
damages) under section 84 as the court considers
appropriate against the person who engaged in the
conduct in contravention of this Act, or a person
involved in that conduct.
(2) The order must be an order that the court
considers will—
(a) redress, in whole or in part, the loss or
damage suffered by the non-party consumers
in relation to the conduct in contravention of
this Act; or
(b) prevent or reduce the loss or damage
suffered, or likely to be suffered, by the non-
party consumers in relation to the conduct in
contravention of this Act.
(3) An application may be made under subsection (1)
even if proceedings in relation to the conduct in
contravention of this Act have not been instituted.
82 Determining whether to make an order under
section 81(1)
(1) In determining whether to make an order under
section 81(1), the court may have regard to the
conduct of the person referred to in that section,
and of the non-party consumers in relation to the
conduct in contravention of this Act, since the
contravention occurred.
(2) In determining whether to make an order under
section 81(1), the court need not make a finding
about either of the following matters—
s. 82
-- 69 of 96 --
Part 8—Remedies and Legal Proceedings
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
65
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(a) which persons are non-party consumers in
relation to the conduct in contravention of
this Act;
(b) the nature of the loss or damage suffered, or
likely to be suffered, by non-party
consumers.
83 When is a non-party consumer bound by an order
under section 81
(1) A non-party consumer is bound by an order made
under section 81 against a person if—
(a) the loss or damage suffered, or likely to be
suffered, by the non-party consumer in
relation to the conduct in contravention of
this Act to which the order relates has been
redressed, prevented or reduced in
accordance with the order; and
(b) the non-party consumer has accepted the
redress, prevention or reduction.
(2) Any other order made under section 81 that relates
to that loss or damage has no effect in relation to
the non-party consumer.
(3) Despite any other provision of any other Act or
law of Victoria, or of the Commonwealth, or of
any other State or a Territory, no claim, action or
demand may be made or taken against the person
by the non-party consumer in relation to that loss
or damage.
84 What kinds of orders can be made?
(1) Without limiting the generality of section 80
or 81, the orders that a court may make under any
of those sections against a person (the respondent)
include any or all of the following—
s. 83
-- 70 of 96 --
Part 8—Remedies and Legal Proceedings
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
66
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(a) an order declaring the whole or any part of a
contract of insurance made between the
respondent and a person (the injured person)
who suffered, or is likely to suffer, the loss
or damage referred to in those sections, or of
a collateral arrangement relating to the
contract of insurance—
(i) to be void; and
(ii) if the court considers it appropriate, to
have been void ab initio or void at all
times on and after a date specified in
the order which may be a date that is
before the date on which the order is
made;
(b) an order—
(i) varying a contract of insurance made
between the respondent and the injured
person who suffered, or is likely to
suffer, the loss or damage referred to in
that section, or a collateral arrangement
relating to the contract of insurance in
the manner specified in the order; and
(ii) if the court considers it appropriate,
declare the contract or arrangement to
have had effect as so varied on and
after a date specified in the order which
may be a date that is before the date on
which the order is made;
(c) an order refusing to enforce any or all of the
provisions of a contract of insurance made
between the respondent and the injured
person who suffered, or is likely to suffer,
the loss or damage referred to in that section,
or of a collateral arrangement relating to the
contract of insurance;
s. 84
-- 71 of 96 --
Part 8—Remedies and Legal Proceedings
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
67
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(d) an order directing the respondent to refund
money or return property to the injured
person;
(e) an order that an amount specified by the
court be paid into the Victorian Consumer
Law Fund.
(2) Without limiting the generality of section 80 or
subsection (1), the court may also make an order
directing the respondent to pay the injured person
the amount of the loss or damage.
85 Power of court to make orders
A court may make an order under this Division
whether or not the court grants an injunction or
makes an order under any other provision of this
Act.
86 Interaction with Divisions 1 and 3
This Division does not limit the generality or
application of Divisions 1 and 3 of this Part.
Division 3—General
87 Prosecutions of offences
Despite section 7 of the Criminal Procedure Act
2009 a prosecution for an offence under this Act
may be commenced not later than 31 December
2014.
88 Who can bring proceedings for offences?
(1) Proceedings for an offence against this Act may
only be brought by—
(a) the Monitor; or
(b) a person authorised by the Monitor for the
purposes of this section.
s. 85
-- 72 of 96 --
Part 8—Remedies and Legal Proceedings
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
68
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(2) In proceedings for an offence against this Act it
must be presumed, in the absence of evidence to
the contrary, that the person bringing the
proceedings was authorised to bring the
proceedings.
89 Contraventions by bodies corporate
(1) If a body corporate contravenes or commits an
offence against any provision of this Act, each
officer of the body corporate is deemed to have
contravened the same provision if the officer
knowingly authorised or permitted the
contravention.
(2) A person may be proceeded against and, in the
case of an offence, convicted under a provision in
accordance with subsection (1) whether or not the
body corporate has been proceeded against under
that provision.
(3) Nothing in this section affects any liability
imposed on a body corporate for a contravention
of this Act by the body corporate.
90 Conduct by officers, employees or agents
(1) If, in a proceeding under this Act in respect of
conduct that is engaged in by a body corporate
and to which this Act applies, it is necessary to
establish the state of mind of the body corporate,
it is sufficient to show—
(a) that an officer, employee or agent of the
body corporate engaged in that conduct
within the scope of the actual or apparent
authority of the officer, employee or agent;
and
(b) that the officer, employee or agent had that
state of mind.
s. 89
-- 73 of 96 --
Part 8—Remedies and Legal Proceedings
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
69
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(2) The following conduct engaged in on behalf of a
body corporate is also taken, for the purposes of
this Act, to have been engaged in by the body
corporate—
(a) conduct by an officer, employee or agent of
the body corporate within the scope of the
actual or apparent authority of the officer,
employee or agent; or
(b) conduct by any other person—
(i) at the direction of an officer, employee
or agent of the body corporate; or
(ii) with the consent or agreement
(whether express or implied) of such
an officer, employee or agent—
if the giving of the direction, consent or
agreement is within the scope of the actual or
apparent authority of the officer, employee
or agent.
(3) If, in a proceeding under this Act in respect of
conduct that is engaged in by a person
(the principal) other than a body corporate and to
which this Act applies, it is necessary to establish
the state of mind of the principal, it is sufficient to
show—
(a) that an employee or agent of the principal
engaged in that conduct within the scope of
the actual or apparent authority or the
employee or agent; and
(b) that the employee or agent had that state of
mind.
(4) The following conduct engaged in on behalf of a
person (the principal) other than a body corporate
is also taken, for the purposes of this Act, to have
been engaged in by the principal—
s. 90
-- 74 of 96 --
Part 8—Remedies and Legal Proceedings
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
70
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(a) conduct by an employee or agent of the
principal within the scope of the actual or
apparent authority of the employee or agent;
or
(b) conduct by any other person—
(i) at the direction of an employee or agent
of the principal; or
(ii) with the consent or agreement
(whether express or implied) of such
an employee or agent—
if the giving of the direction, consent or
agreement is within the scope of the actual or
apparent authority of the employee or agent.
(5) If—
(a) a person other than a body corporate is
convicted of an offence; and
(b) subsection (3) or (4) applied in relation to the
conviction on the basis that the person was
the principal mentioned in that subsection;
and
(c) the person would not have been convicted of
the offence if that subsection had not been
enacted—
the person is not liable to be punished by
imprisonment for that offence.
(6) A reference in this section to the state of mind of a
person includes a reference to the knowledge,
intention, opinion, belief or purpose of the person
and the person's reasons for the intention, opinion,
belief or purpose.
s. 90
-- 75 of 96 --
Part 8—Remedies and Legal Proceedings
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
71
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
91 Interpretation
A reference in this Division to a person involved
in a contravention of this Act means a reference to
a person who—
(a) has aided, abetted, counselled or procured
the contravention;
(b) has induced, whether by threats or promises
or otherwise, the contravention;
(c) has been in any way, directly or indirectly,
knowingly concerned in or party to, the
contravention;
(d) has conspired with others to effect the
contravention.
92 Undertakings
(1) The Monitor may accept a written undertaking
given by a person in connection with a matter in
relation to which the Monitor has a power or
function under this Act.
(2) The person may withdraw or vary an undertaking
at any time, if the person has first obtained the
consent of the Monitor.
(3) The Monitor, with the consent of the person who
gave an undertaking, may apply, at any time, to
the Magistrates' Court for an order directing the
person to comply with the undertaking.
(4) On an application under subsection (3), the
Magistrates' Court may by order direct the person
who gave the undertaking to comply with the
undertaking.
(5) If the Monitor considers that the person who gave
the undertaking has breached any of its terms, the
Monitor may apply to the Magistrates' Court for
an order under subsection (6).
s. 91
-- 76 of 96 --
Part 8—Remedies and Legal Proceedings
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
72
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(6) If the Magistrates' Court is satisfied that the
person has breached a term of the undertaking, the
Magistrates' Court may make all or any of the
following orders—
(a) an order directing the person to comply with
that term of the undertaking;
(b) an order directing the person to pay to the
State an amount up to the amount of any
financial benefit that the person has obtained
directly or indirectly and that is reasonably
attributable to the breach;
(c) any order that the Magistrates' Court
considers appropriate directing the person to
compensate any other person who has
suffered loss, injury or damage as a result of
the breach;
(d) any other order that the Magistrates' Court
considers appropriate.
(7) If a body corporate is found to have breached an
undertaking, each officer of the body corporate is
deemed to have so breached the undertaking if the
officer knowingly authorised or permitted the
breach and the Magistrates' Court may, against the
officer, make all or any of the orders set out in
subsection (6) that the Magistrates' Court
considers appropriate.
93 Copy of undertaking
The Monitor must give a copy of an undertaking
under section 92 to the person who made the
undertaking.
s. 93
-- 77 of 96 --
Part 8—Remedies and Legal Proceedings
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
73
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
94 Register of undertakings
(1) The Monitor must—
(a) maintain a register of undertakings; and
(b) register each undertaking in the register of
undertakings.
(2) The register of undertakings must include the
following—
(a) the name and address of the person who gave
the undertaking;
(b) the date of the undertaking;
(c) a copy of the undertaking.
(3) The register of undertakings may be inspected by
any person at any reasonable time, without charge.
95 Injunctions to restrain conduct
(1) The Monitor or any other person may apply to the
Supreme Court, County Court or Magistrates'
Court for the grant of an injunction restraining a
person from engaging in conduct that
constitutes—
(a) a contravention of a provision of this Act; or
(b) attempting or conspiring to contravene such
a provision; or
(c) aiding, abetting, counselling or procuring a
person to contravene such a provision; or
(d) inducing or attempting to induce a person,
whether by threats, promises or otherwise, to
contravene such a provision; or
(e) being in any way directly or indirectly,
knowingly concerned in, or party to, the
contravention by a person of such a
provision.
s. 94
-- 78 of 96 --
Part 8—Remedies and Legal Proceedings
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
74
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(2) The Supreme Court, County Court or Magistrates'
Court may grant an injunction restraining a person
from engaging in conduct of the kind referred to
in paragraphs (a) to (e) of subsection (1)—
(a) if the Supreme Court, County Court or
Magistrates' Court is satisfied that the person
is engaging in or has been engaging in
conduct of that kind, whether or not it
appears to the Supreme Court, County Court
or Magistrates' Court that the person intends
to engage again or continue to engage in the
conduct; or
(b) if it appears to the Supreme Court, County
Court or Magistrates' Court that, in the event
that the injunction is not granted, it is likely
that the person will engage in conduct of that
kind, whether or not that person has
previously engaged in conduct of that kind
and whether or not there is an imminent
danger of substantial damage to any person if
the first-mentioned person engages in
conduct of that kind; or
(c) if the Supreme Court, County Court or
Magistrates' Court determines it to be
appropriate, by consent of all the parties to
the proceedings, whether or not the person
has engaged in, or is likely to engage in,
conduct of that kind.
(3) An application for an injunction under this section
may be made ex parte.
96 Injunctions to do an act or thing
(1) The Supreme Court or the County Court, on the
application of the Monitor or any other person,
may grant an injunction requiring a person to do
any act or thing if the Supreme Court or County
s. 96
-- 79 of 96 --
Part 8—Remedies and Legal Proceedings
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
75
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
Court is satisfied that the person is engaging in or
has been engaging in conduct that constitutes—
(a) a contravention of any provision of this Act;
or
(b) attempting or conspiring to contravene such
a provision; or
(c) aiding, abetting, counselling or procuring a
person to contravene such a provision; or
(d) inducing or attempting to induce a person,
whether by threats, promises or otherwise, to
contravene such a provision; or
(e) being in any way directly or indirectly,
knowingly concerned in, or party to, the
contravention by a person of such a
provision.
(2) The power of the Supreme Court or County Court
under this section to grant an injunction requiring
a person to do an act or thing may be exercised—
(a) whether or not it appears to the Supreme
Court or County Court that the person
intends to refuse or fail again, or to continue
to refuse or fail, to do that act or thing; and
(b) whether or not the person has previously
refused or failed to do that act or thing; and
(c) whether or not there is an imminent danger
of substantial damage to any person if the
first person refuses or fails to do that act or
thing.
(3) Without limiting subsection (1), an injunction
under this section may require a person—
(a) to institute a training program for the
person's employees in relation to compliance
with this Act;
(b) to refund money to purchasers;
s. 96
-- 80 of 96 --
Part 8—Remedies and Legal Proceedings
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
76
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(c) to disclose information about the person's
business activities or business associates;
(d) to honour any promise made in the course of
misleading or deceptive conduct or in a false
representation.
(4) An application for an injunction under this section
may be made ex parte.
97 Interim injunctions
(1) The Supreme Court, County Court or Magistrates'
Court may grant an interim injunction pending
determination of an application under section 95,
if, in the opinion of the Supreme Court, County
Court or Magistrates' Court it is desirable to do
so—
(a) whether or not it appears to the Supreme
Court, County Court or Magistrates' Court
that the person intends to engage in or
continue to engage in conduct of the kind
referred to in paragraphs (a) to (e) of
section 95(1); or
(b) whether or not the person has previously
engaged in conduct of that kind and whether
or not there is an imminent danger of
substantial damage to any person if the first-
mentioned person engages in conduct of that
kind.
(2) The Supreme Court or County Court may grant an
interim injunction pending determination of an
application under section 96 in relation to an act
or thing, if, in the opinion of the Supreme Court or
County Court it is desirable to do so—
(a) whether or not it appears to the Supreme
Court or County Court that the person
intends to refuse or fail again, or to continue
to refuse or fail, to do that act or thing; and
s. 97
-- 81 of 96 --
Part 8—Remedies and Legal Proceedings
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
77
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(b) whether or not the person has previously
refused or failed to do that act or thing.
(3) An application for an injunction under this section
may be made ex parte.
98 Power to rescind or vary injunctions
The Court may rescind or vary an injunction
granted by it under section 95 or 96 or an interim
injunction granted by it under section 97.
99 Undertakings as to costs
(1) In any application under section 95, 96 or 97,
subject to subsection (2), if—
(a) the Court would, but for this subsection,
require a person to give an undertaking as to
costs; and
(b) the Monitor gives the undertaking—
the Court must accept the undertaking by the
Monitor and must not require a further
undertaking from any other person.
(2) In an application for an injunction under
section 96 or 97, if the application has been made
by the Monitor and if the Court has determined to
grant an interim injunction, the Court must not, as
a condition of granting the interim injunction,
require the applicant or any other person to give
any undertaking as to costs.
100 Powers of court if requirement of Monitor or
inspector not complied with
(1) Subject to subsection (3), if the Monitor is
satisfied that a person has, without reasonable
excuse, failed to comply with a requirement under
section 18 or 19, the Monitor may certify that
failure to a court.
s. 98
-- 82 of 96 --
Part 8—Remedies and Legal Proceedings
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
78
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(2) Subject to subsection (3), if an inspector is
satisfied that a person has, without reasonable
excuse, failed to comply with a requirement of the
inspector under section 71, the inspector may
certify that failure to a court.
(3) The Monitor or an inspector cannot certify a
failure to a court under subsection (1) or (2) if the
person to whom the failure relates has been
charged with an offence against section 18(2),
19(3) or 65.
(4) If the Monitor or an inspector so certifies under
subsection (1) or (2), the court may inquire into
the case and may order the person to comply with
the requirement within the period specified by the
court.
(5) A certification of the Monitor under subsection (1)
is to be taken to be evidence that a person has
failed to comply with a requirement under
section 18 or 19, unless the person adduces
evidence that—
(a) the requirement was complied with; or
(b) there was a reasonable excuse for failing to
comply with the requirement.
(6) If a proceeding is brought under this section in
relation to a failure to comply with a requirement,
a person to whom the failure relates cannot be
charged with an offence under section 18(2),
19(3) or 65 in respect of that failure.
101 Non-punitive orders—Corrective advertising orders
(1) A court may, on the application of the Monitor,
make a corrective advertising order in relation to a
person if the court is satisfied that the person has
contravened, or has been involved in the
contravention of, a pecuniary penalty provision.
s. 101
-- 83 of 96 --
Part 8—Remedies and Legal Proceedings
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
79
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(2) In this section, a corrective advertising order, in
relation to a person, means—
(a) an order that requires the person to disclose,
in the way and to the persons specified in the
order, such information as is so specified,
being information that the person has
possession of or access to; or
(b) an order that requires the person to publish,
at the person's expense and in the way
specified in the order, an advertisement in
the terms specified in, or determined in
accordance with, the order.
(3) This section does not limit a court's powers under
any other provision of this Act.
102 Punitive orders—Adverse publicity orders
(1) If in any proceedings under this Act—
(a) a person is found guilty of an offence against
this Act; or
(b) a person is found to have contravened a
pecuniary penalty provision—
the court, in addition to any other penalty it may
fix or order it may make, may, on the application
of the Monitor, make an adverse publicity order in
relation to the person.
(2) In this section, an adverse publicity order, in
relation to a person, means an order that—
(a) requires the person to disclose, in the way
and to the persons specified in the order,
such information as is so specified, being
information that the person has possession of
or access to; or
s. 102
-- 84 of 96 --
Part 8—Remedies and Legal Proceedings
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
80
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(b) requires the person to publish, at the person's
expense and in the way specified in the
order, an advertisement in the terms
specified in, or determined in accordance
with, the order.
(3) This section does not limit a court's powers under
any other provision of this Act.
103 Defences
(1) Subject to subsection (2), in a prosecution under
this Act, it is a defence if the accused
establishes—
(a) that the contravention in respect of which the
proceeding was instituted was due to a
reasonable mistake of fact, including a
mistake of fact caused by a reasonable
reliance on information supplied by another
person; or
(b) that—
(i) the contravention in respect of which
the proceeding was instituted was due
to the act or default of another person,
to an accident or to some other cause
beyond the control of the accused; and
(ii) the accused took reasonable precautions
and exercised due diligence to avoid the
contravention.
(2) In subsection (1)(a) and (b), another person does
not include a person who was—
(a) an employee or an agent of the accused; or
(b) in the case of an accused being a body
corporate, an officer, employee or agent of
the accused—
at the time when the contravention occurred.
s. 103
-- 85 of 96 --
Part 8—Remedies and Legal Proceedings
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
81
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(3) If a defence provided by subsection (1) involves
an allegation that a contravention was due to
reliance on information supplied by another
person or to the act or default of another person,
the accused is not, without leave of the court,
entitled to rely on that defence unless the accused
has, not later than 14 days before the day on
which the hearing of the proceeding commences,
served on the person by whom the proceeding was
instituted, a notice in writing giving such
information that would identify or assist in the
identification of the other person as was then in
the possession of the accused.
(4) In a proceeding under this Act for a contravention
of section 31 committed by the publication of an
advertisement, it is a defence if the accused
establishes that—
(a) the accused is a person whose business is to
publish or arrange for the publication of
advertisements; and
(b) that the accused received the advertisement
for publication in the ordinary course of
business and did not know and had no reason
to suspect that its publication would amount
to a contravention of this Act.
104 Findings in proceedings to be evidence
In a proceeding against a person under
section 105, a finding of fact by the Court made in
proceedings under section 95, 96, 97, 100, 101
or 102, in which that person has been found to
have contravened, or to have been involved in a
contravention of, a provision of this Act is
evidence of that fact and the finding may be
proved by production of a document under the
seal of the Court from which the finding appears.
s. 104
-- 86 of 96 --
Part 8—Remedies and Legal Proceedings
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
82
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
105 Orders against persons found to have contravened
this Act
(1) In any proceedings for an offence against, or a
contravention of, this Act, the court may make
any order it considers fair if the court finds that—
(a) the person against whom the proceedings
were brought (the accused) has contravened
a provision of this Act; and
(b) another person (the injured person) has
suffered or may suffer loss or damage as a
result of the contravention of this Act.
(2) Without limiting subsection (1), the orders that
may be made under this section include—
(a) an order that the whole or any part of a
contract between the accused and the injured
person which is affected by the
contravention or any agreement collateral to
such a contract is void on and from the time
specified in the order; or
(b) an order that the contract or agreement is
varied in the manner specified in the order
and may specify in the order that the
variation takes effect from the time specified
in the order; or
(c) an order that all or any of the provisions in
the contract are not to be enforced; or
(d) an order that the accused refund to the
injured person money paid by that person
under the contract or agreement; or
(e) an order that the accused pay the amount of
any loss or damage suffered by the injured
person as a result of the breach to the injured
person; or
s. 105
-- 87 of 96 --
Part 8—Remedies and Legal Proceedings
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
83
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(f) an order that the accused supply services
required to be supplied under the contract or
agreement to the injured person; or
(g) an order declaring that the accused has
contravened a provision of this Act.
(3) In any proceedings under section 95 or 97, if the
Court finds that—
(a) a party to the proceedings has contravened
the provisions of this Act; and
(b) that another person has suffered or is likely
to suffer loss or damage as a result of that
contravention—
the Court may make any order against the party to
the proceedings that might be made against an
accused under subsection (1).
(4) A reference in this section to a contract does not
include a reference to a contract of insurance.
(5) The Court may also make an order under this
section against a person involved in a
contravention of a provision of this Act.
106 Public warning statements
If satisfied that it is in the public interest to do so,
the Monitor may publish a public statement or
issue a public warning, identifying and giving
information about the following—
(a) price exploitation and prohibited conduct and
persons who engage in those practices;
(b) any other matter that adversely affects or
may adversely affect the interests of persons
in connection with the acquisition by them of
insurance services.
s. 106
-- 88 of 96 --
Part 8—Remedies and Legal Proceedings
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
84
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
107 Complaints and evidence are privileged
If a person in good faith—
(a) makes a complaint to the Monitor under
section 44; or
(b) produces or gives a document or any
information or evidence to the Monitor or an
inspector in relation to a matter that
constitutes or may constitute a contravention
of this Act—
the person is not liable in any way for any loss,
damage or injury suffered by another person by
reason only of the making of that complaint or the
production or giving of that document,
information or evidence.
__________________
s. 107
-- 89 of 96 --
Part 9—General
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
85
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
PART 9—GENERAL
108 When is a person not liable?
(1) A person is not liable to be prosecuted for an
offence for a contravention of a provision of this
Act or to pay a pecuniary penalty or award of
compensation under this Act if—
(a) conduct which is a contravention of this Act
is substantially the same as conduct
constituting a contravention of any other
Victorian law or of a law of the
Commonwealth; and
(b) the conduct may make the person liable to
prosecution for an offence or to pay a
pecuniary penalty or award of compensation
under any other Victorian law or a law of the
Commonwealth; and
(c) the person has been convicted of the offence
or ordered to pay a pecuniary penalty or
award of compensation under that other
Victorian law or law of the Commonwealth.
(2) This provision is to be construed as being in
addition to section 34.
109 Power to make request to the Essential Services
Commission
(1) The Monitor may, with the consent of the Minister
administering the Essential Services
Commission Act 2001, by notice in writing
request the Essential Services Commission—
(a) to provide to the Monitor any information
specified in the notice which is in the
possession of the Essential Services
Commission; or
s. 108
-- 90 of 96 --
Part 9—General
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
86
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(b) to obtain from any person and provide to the
Monitor any information specified in the
notice—
which the Monitor considers on reasonable
grounds is necessary to enable the Monitor to
perform his or her functions or exercise his or her
powers under this Act.
(2) The Essential Services Commission must comply
with a request under subsection (1).
110 Report
(1) The Monitor must, within 28 days after the end of
each quarter, give the Minister a written report on
the performance of the functions of the Monitor
during the quarter.
(2) Without limiting subsection (1), a report must
include particulars of—
(a) any notices given under section 29;
(b) any variations or revocations of notices
given under section 29.
(3) As soon as practicable after the Minister receives
a report under subsection (1), the Minister must
publish the report.
(4) For the purposes of subsection (1), quarter means
the period ending on each 30 March, 30 June,
30 September and 31 December in each year.
(5) The Minister may by written notice request the
Monitor to provide a report to the Minister on the
performance of the functions of the Monitor either
generally or in respect of a specified matter.
s. 110
-- 91 of 96 --
Part 9—General
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
87
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(6) A written notice under subsection (5) must
specify—
(a) the matters to be addressed in the report; and
(b) the date by which the report must be
provided to the Minister.
111 Regulations
(1) The Governor in Council may make regulations
for or with respect to any matter or thing required
or permitted by this Act to be prescribed or
necessary to be prescribed to give effect to this
Act.
(2) The regulations—
(a) may be of general or specially limited
application;
(b) may differ according to differences in time,
place or circumstance;
(c) may leave any matter or thing to be from
time to time determined, applied, dispensed
with or regulated by a specified person or
class of persons;
(d) may provide in a specified case or class of
case for the exemption of persons or things
or a class of persons or things from any of
the provisions of the regulations, whether
unconditionally or on specified conditions
and either wholly or to the extent specified;
(e) may confer powers or impose duties in
connection with the regulations on any
specified person or specified class of
persons;
s. 111
-- 92 of 96 --
Part 9—General
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
88
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(f) may apply, adopt or incorporate with or
without modification, any matter contained
in any document, code, standard, rule,
specification or method formulated, issued,
prescribed or published by any person—
(i) wholly or partially or as amended by
the regulations; or
(ii) as formulated, issued, prescribed or
published at the time the regulations are
made or at any time before then; or
(iii) as formulated, issued, prescribed or
published from time to time;
(g) may impose a penalty not exceeding
20 penalty units for a contravention of the
regulations.
112 Amendment of the Australian Consumer Law and
Fair Trading Act 2012
After section 134(2)(b) of the Australian
Consumer Law and Fair Trading Act 2012
insert—
"(ba) any amount ordered by a court under
section 80 or 81 of the Fire Services Levy
Monitor Act 2012 to be paid into the
Fund;".
113 Amendment of the Essential Services Commission
Act 2001
(1) After section 10(la) of the Essential Services
Commission Act 2001 insert—
"(lb) when requested to do so by the Fire Services
Levy Monitor under section 109 of the Fire
Services Levy Monitor Act 2012, provide,
or obtain and provide, information to the Fire
Services Levy Monitor as specified in a
notice under that section;".
s. 112
-- 93 of 96 --
Part 9—General
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
89
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(2) Section 10(lb) of the Essential Services
Commission Act 2001 is repealed.
114 Amendment of the Fire Services Property Levy
Act 2012
(1) In section 85 of the Fire Services Property Levy
Act 2012 insert the following definition—
"fire services levy has the same meaning as it has
in section 3 of the Fire Services Levy
Monitor Act 2012;".
(2) In the Fire Services Property Levy Act 2012—
(a) in section 36(2)(a) after "under" insert "the";
(b) in section 76(2) for "addressed to the"
substitute "addressed to";
(c) in section 110(2) for "is" substitute "are".
115 Amendment of Public Administration Act 2004
(1) After section 16(1)(f) of the Public
Administration Act 2004 insert—
"(faa) the Fire Services Levy Monitor in relation to
the office of the Fire Services Levy Monitor
within the meaning of the Fire Services
Levy Monitor Act 2012;".
(2) Section 16(1)(faa) of the Public Administration
Act 2004 is repealed.
116 Transitional provisions
After section 137 of the Australian Consumer
Law and Fair Trading Act 2012 insert—
"Division 6—Fire Services Levy Monitor
Act 2012
137A Director to succeed Fire Services Levy
Monitor
(1) In this section, relevant day means
31 December 2014.
s. 114
-- 94 of 96 --
Part 9—General
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
90
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
(2) The Director is, by force of this section,
substituted as a party to any proceedings
pending or existing in any court immediately
before the relevant day to which the Fire
Services Levy Monitor was a party.
(3) Any act, matter or thing of a continuing
nature which was commenced by the Fire
Services Levy Monitor before the relevant
day may be continued and completed by the
Director.".
117 Sunset
This Act is repealed on 31 December 2014.
═══════════════
s. 117
-- 95 of 96 --
Fire Services Levy Monitor Act 2012
No. 81 of 2012
91
Authorised by the Chief Parliamentary Counsel
ENDNOTES
† Minister's second reading speech—
Legislative Assembly: 14 November 2012
Legislative Council: 29 November 2012
The long title for the Bill for this Act was "A Bill for an Act to provide
for the establishment, functions and powers of the Fire Services Levy
Monitor, to consequentially amend certain Acts and for other purposes."
Endnotes
-- 96 of 96 --